Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
|
General Cooking (rec.food.cooking) For general food and cooking discussion. Foods of all kinds, food procurement, cooking methods and techniques, eating, etc. |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Tuesday, June 17, 2014 12:55:28 PM UTC-6, Travis McGee wrote:
> http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/...-vs-margarine/ > > > > The generational battle of butter vs. margarine > > By Roberto A. Ferdman June 17 at 12:21 PM > > > > The 100-plus year war between butter and margarine, America's two > > favorite fatty spreads, has been a battle of cultural norms, nutritional > > headwinds, a bit of circumstance, and, of course, cash rich marketing > > campaigns. > > > > At times the tussle has proved a tad lopsided�for over 50 years > > margarine seemed markedly outmatched. Back in 1911, the average American > > ate almost 19 pounds of butter per year, the most ever, according to the > > USDA. Meanwhile, margarine consumption barely broke a single pound per > > person per year. Among the butter industry's many efforts to mitigate > > the growth of the competing spread was a mandate, upheld in many states, > > disallowing the sale of yellow margarine. In an effort to circumvent the > > restriction, clear margarine blocks were often sold with a side of > > yellow dye. > > > > World World II, however, brought butter shortages and, with them, the > > rise of butter's arch nemesis. It wasn't until 1957, when Americans ate > > as much margarine as they did butter�8.5 pounds per year�that margarine, > > which was marketed as both a healthier and cheaper butter alternative, > > opened the spread in its favor. Fat had become a food faux pas, and the > > margarine industry used its widening wallet to tout margarine's supposed > > health appeal. "The massive advertising of health claims for margarine > > transformed a generally disreputable product of inferior quality and > > flavor into a great commercial success," William G. Rothstein wrote in > > his book Public Health and the Risk Factor. > > > > Even Eleanor Roosevelt came to margarine's aid. "That's what I've spread > > on my toast," she said in a 1959 commercial for Good Luck margarine. > > > > The thing about advertising is that it often works. For some 50 years > > thereafter, it was butter that was left to congeal in the fridge. In > > 1976, at the peak of America's love affair with margarine, per capita > > consumption towered to just under 12 pounds per year, or nearly three > > times that of butter, according to the USDA. > > > > Today, however, amid a complete reversal in both consumer preferences > > and nutritional science�recent studies have challenged the notion that > > consuming saturated fats is tied to greater risks of heart > > disease�margarine's marketing efforts have lost their appeal and the > > narratives have reversed themselves. Growing concerns over processed > > foods and a simultaneous, and ferocious, revival of the American > > appetite for natural fats has turned the tables�and this time, > > seemingly, for good. Even one of the world's largest margarine makers > > has conceded as much. > > > > After announcing the return of butter back in March, Mark Bittman wrote > > in defense of real food and real fats just last week. "Eat real food and > > your fat intake will probably be fine," he said. If America's taste in > > fatty spreads is any indication, the country seems to have already > > caught on. Butter consumption is up more than 21% since its lowest > > reading in 1997, while margarine consumption is down 70% since its peak > > in the mid-1970s. > > > > Put another way, the average American hasn't eaten this much butter > > since 1972, or�and perhaps more incredibly�this little margarine since 1942. We buy only real butter. It tastes better, it cooks better, and I like it. The amount we use is so small that I am not going to worry about the fat intake from my butter. A pound of butter lasts months and months unless I go crazy and do some baking. I love to bake but have no one to feed it to, and we don't need it!! DaleP |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Difference between Butter and Margarine | General Cooking | |||
So...why use margarine instead of butter? | General Cooking | |||
Butter/Margarine | Baking | |||
Butter Vs. Margarine | Historic | |||
margarine/butter question | General Cooking |