Is it okay to use idophor to sanitize for wine making? I have a gallon of it
I use for sanitization when brewing beer.

--

Just Brew It!
Johnny Mc

To E-mail me, just cut the "CRAP"!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Johnny Mc wrote:
> >> Is it okay to use idophor to sanitize for wine making? I have a
gallon of
> >> it I use for sanitization when brewing beer.

I wouldn't use it as a no rinse sanitizer. Any idophor remaining can
neutralize some of the SO2 added to the wine.

> >>
> > It's better than OK, because it's a better sanitizer than SO2.

I disagree. SO2 is a very effective sanitizer if used at proper
concentrations and if some residual remains on the equipment you're not
adding something you wouldn't normally add anyway.

>>I use Star
> > San for both my wine and beer sanitizing.

I occasionally use Star San also, just to vary my regiment once in a
while, but everything gets a rinse in Pot. Meta. solution before
storage/use.


Andy

"JEP62" > wrote in message
oups.com...
> SO2 is a very effective sanitizer if used at proper
> concentrations and if some residual remains on the equipment you're not
> adding something you wouldn't normally add anyway.

Although sulfite is an effective sanitizer, Iodophor is actually a
_sterilizer_. It kills anything it comes in contact with. You're correct
in that it is _not_ a no-rinse product. You wouldn't want any residue to
get into your wine or beer.

Tom S

Tom S wrote:
> Although sulfite is an effective sanitizer, Iodophor is actually a
> _sterilizer_. It kills anything it comes in contact with. You're
correct
> in that it is _not_ a no-rinse product. You wouldn't want any
residue to
> get into your wine or beer.
>
> Tom S

The reason for my previous post is there appears to be some
misconception about santizers in the home brewing scene.

They tend not to use SO2 because some feel it is ineffective due to
winemakers saying it will not sanitize a wine must, plus all of the bad
press sulfites get. This is true because of the limit on how much
sulfite we add to the must. In the concentration used in a sanitizing
solution, it is very effective.

Idophor is commonly used as a no rinse santizer in homebrewing at 12.5
ppm. To me this is just plain wrong. I'm much more comfortable using
sulfite solution as a no rinse sanitizer than Idophor because I know
the sulfite will not harm the beer/wine. It may even have some benefit
due to it's antioxidant properties and the way it can bind to other
chemicals (like chlorine) than can cause other problems.

Star San is an acid based sanitizer and I don't see any real problem
using it as no rinse, but I'm not sure exactly what else is in there
besides acid. It tends to foam up so I'm guessing that it's not just an
acid solution.

Andy