View Single Post
  #3 (permalink)   Report Post  
Steve Grant
 
Posts: n/a
Default Verget Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles '93

"Dale Williams" > wrote in message
...
> In article >, "Steve Grant"
> > writes:
>
> >
> >I've opened two bottles of these recently and been sorely disappointed

both
> >times. All acid, no fruit. Did I buy too late? (Mixed case lot at an
> >Acker-Merrall-Condit auction late last year.) Just get a bad six-lot?

I've
> >had good luck with other wines from Verget; is this just a clunker that I
> >should write off to experience?
> >

>
> Haven't had this particular wine, but I can't say I've been impressed with

any
> '93 white Burg recently. Liked some Niellons and Ramonets a few years ago.

But
> the vintage was always a bit thin on the fruit, and the acidity levels

quite
> high (I'm a person who likes high-acid wines, but with some balance). When

you
> combine thin fruit, high acid, and lots of wood (haven't had this wine,

but
> Guffens is pretty oak-oriented), it's not a real recipe for aging.
>
> As you haven't liked the 2 you've had, I'd try the following:
> 1) vary serving temp. Have you been serving fairly cold? Warmer temps seem

to
> de-accentuate acidity, and might even bring out more fruit


Dale, you must have peeked! You're right that I've been serving this cold.

> 2) I find white Burgs respond well sometimes to air. Decanting might help

(not
> something I normally recommend for wines that might be getting past it,

but
> sounds like little to lose here).


Easily done, and you're quite right about the risk / reward.

> 3) put them up on winecommune or winebid. Or offer them in trde if you

have a
> local group


4) Toss some into a bechamel sauce and see what happens?