FoodBanter.com

FoodBanter.com (https://www.foodbanter.com/)
-   General Cooking (https://www.foodbanter.com/general-cooking/)
-   -   closed door broiling (https://www.foodbanter.com/general-cooking/177653-closed-door-broiling.html)

Jean B.[_1_] 08-10-2009 02:12 PM

closed door broiling
 
(which sucks, and which I never encountered before I got my lousy
KA oven)... I am too lazy to look at the model number of my
oven--and note that even in nonconvection mode the door must be
closed. Here are some quotes:

"Get Past The Traditional Downfalls Of Broiling

Let's say that tonight you're preparing a little Italian cuisine.
On the stovetop, your puttanesca sauce is just about finished
reducing at a moderate simmer and the pasta is nearly al dente.
You've just place the bruschetta into the oven on a baking sheet
to toast under the broil element, but, because you have to leave
the oven door slightly ajar while broiling, its difficult to reach
the sauce and pasta over the roaring heat lpouring out of the open
oven door. Using the broiler on traditional ranges can be
frustrating and inconvenient. Applying its convection cooking mode
to broiling, your KERS807SSS's Closed-Door Convection Broil lets
you broil to your heart's content, with the door closed all the
while. Enjoy bruschetta toasted under the broiler, while keeping
the oven door closed and appreciating easy access to your stovetop
delights."
http://www.vanns.com/shop/servlet/it...aid-kers807sss

or

http://tinyurl.com/yceu75b

# Oven Features
# Cooking System Thermal Oven
# Hidden Bake Element CleanBake™ Hidden Element
# Bake Yes
# Broil Closed-Door with Full & Center Selections
# Cleaning System Self Clean with Variable Soil Level/Time Selections
# Delayed Cooking Delayed Cooking & Cleaning
# Bread Proofing Yes
# Sabbath Mode Star-K Kosher Certified

http://www.universal-akb.com/kebk171sbl.html

etc.

Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? Whatever it is, it is
awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. (And I will make
sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)
--
Jean B.

notbob 08-10-2009 02:24 PM

closed door broiling
 
On 2009-10-08, Jean B. > wrote:

> # Sabbath Mode Star-K Kosher Certified


I actually looked this up. Un....beeelievable.

nb

Giusi 08-10-2009 02:41 PM

closed door broiling
 

"Jean B." ha scritto nel messaggio
> Let's say that tonight you're preparing a little Italian cuisine.


They need to come over for some Italian cookery lessons, say I.


> You've just place the bruschetta into the oven on a baking sheet > to
> toast under the broil element, but, because you have to leave > the oven
> door slightly ajar while broiling, its difficult to reach > the sauce and
> pasta over the roaring heat lpouring out of the open oven door. Using the
> broiler on traditional ranges can be > frustrating and inconvenient.


1. Broiling is a second rate way of making bruschetta.
2. It's just this range, makes that point, actually, by saying it is
different from all other electric ranges.



notbob 08-10-2009 02:47 PM

closed door broiling
 
On 2009-10-08, Giusi > wrote:

> 1. Broiling is a second rate way of making bruschetta.


What, pray tell, is the first rate way?

nb

Giusi 08-10-2009 02:54 PM

closed door broiling
 

"notbob" ha scritto nel messaggio

wrote:
>
>> 1. Broiling is a second rate way of making bruschetta.

>
> What, pray tell, is the first rate way?
>
> nb


Grill on one side over open flame. We have these cheap little metal things
we use on a gas burner or do them in the FP or on a grill. You should grill
only the top side that gets scraped with garlic.



Andy[_15_] 08-10-2009 02:56 PM

closed door broiling
 
Jean B. said...

> Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? Whatever it is, it is
> awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. (And I will make
> sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)



When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.

That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
much! ;-)

Andy

notbob 08-10-2009 02:58 PM

closed door broiling
 
On 2009-10-08, Giusi > wrote:

> Grill on one side over open flame. We have these cheap little metal things
> we use on a gas burner or do them in the FP or on a grill. You should grill
> only the top side that gets scraped with garlic.


You mean I can't have my chèvre with dried tomatoes and fresh basil
over prosciutto browned? ;)

nb

ViLco 08-10-2009 04:00 PM

closed door broiling
 
Giusi wrote:

> Grill on one side over open flame. We have these cheap little

metal
> things we use on a gas burner or do them in the FP or on a grill.
> You should grill only the top side that gets scraped with garlic.


Once I raised a quasi - riot in a tuscan town, Capalbio, by asking
in a pub if bruschette had to be grilled only on one side or both,
everyone had theyr version. Me, for example, brown both the sides of
the bread but add garlic, salt and oil only on one.
--
Vilco
Mai guardare Trailer park Boys senza
qualcosa da bere a portata di mano



Nancy2 08-10-2009 04:05 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Oct 8, 8:56*am, Andy > wrote:
> Jean B. said...
>
> > Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? *Whatever it is, it is
> > awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. *(And I will make
> > sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)

>
> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
> never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.
>
> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
> much! ;-)
>
> Andy


"Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? I'm confused.

My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. My previous ovens
have always said to do so. I don't know which is correct, but since
the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
usually broil with it closed.

N.

Andy[_15_] 08-10-2009 04:36 PM

closed door broiling
 
Nancy2 said...

> On Oct 8, 8:56*am, Andy > wrote:
>> Jean B. said...
>>
>> > Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? *Whatever it is, it is
>> > awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. *(And I will make
>> > sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)

>>
>> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
>> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly

w
> ill
>> never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.
>>
>> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not

> so
>> much! ;-)
>>
>> Andy

>
> "Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? I'm confused.
>
> My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
> anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. My previous ovens
> have always said to do so. I don't know which is correct, but since
> the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
> usually broil with it closed.
>
> N.



Nancy2,

Right! I oops'd.

The temp sensor could overwork the heating element(s) to maintain the
correct temp if the inside heat could constantly escape.

Maybe let the finished dish rest inside with the door cracked open a bit to
conserve limited counter space??

Best,

Andy

Kalmia 08-10-2009 04:38 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Oct 8, 11:05*am, Nancy2 > wrote:
> On Oct 8, 8:56*am, Andy > wrote:
>
> > Jean B. said...

>
> > > Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? *Whatever it is, it is
> > > awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. *(And I will make
> > > sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)

>
> > When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
> > surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
> > never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.

>
> > That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
> > much! ;-)

>
> > Andy

>
> "Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? *I'm confused.
>
> My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
> anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. *My previous ovens
> have always said to do so. *I don't know which is correct, but since
> the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
> usually broil with it closed.



I'm glad you said this. My mother always left the door open but I
never understood why. But, dutiful daughter, I left it open until I
wondered why one day. It never did make sense to be heating the
kitchen just to broil something for a few minutes.

My booklet says nada too.

Wasn't there a poll on this a while back?


brooklyn1 08-10-2009 04:54 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Thu, 08 Oct 2009 08:56:17 -0500, Andy > wrote:

>Jean B. said...
>
>> Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? Whatever it is, it is
>> awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. (And I will make
>> sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)

>
>
>When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
>surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
>never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.
>
>That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
>much! ;-)
>
>Andy


You're one of the Bozos... with a stove/range there is no temperature
setting in broil mode. In broil mode the thermostat is bypassed. The
element is either full on or full off. In broil mode the element
remains full on continuously. In bake mode the element cycles fully
on and fully off however often necessary to maintain the set bake
temperature. The element won't burn out quicker from being energized
whether in broil mode or bake mode... elements are self regulating by
wattage rating, same as a light bulb... they are not engineered to get
hotter and hotter until they self destruct.

Toaster ovens operate differently, their primary function is
supposedly to toast, so the element is typically controlled similarly
to an ordinary bread toaster, but with toaster ovens there are many,
many varieties, having all kinds of bells, whistles, and functions...
toaster ovens are multi use appliances, none of which performs nearly
as well as with a dedicated appliance... I've never seen a toaster
oven that toasts bread very well, because they only toast one side at
a time, and I've never seen one where one can set the degree of
doneness... I know of no toaster oven that's worthwhile having for any
reason whatsoever. Anytime I'm in a kitchen where there is a toaster
oven present I know that nobody cooks there.

Andy[_15_] 08-10-2009 05:40 PM

closed door broiling
 
brooklyn1 said...

> Anytime I'm in a kitchen where there is a toaster
> oven present I know that nobody cooks there.



LOLOL!!!

Andy


Jean B.[_1_] 08-10-2009 06:52 PM

closed door broiling
 
Giusi wrote:
> "Jean B." ha scritto nel messaggio
>> Let's say that tonight you're preparing a little Italian cuisine.

>
> They need to come over for some Italian cookery lessons, say I.
>
>
>> You've just place the bruschetta into the oven on a baking sheet > to
>> toast under the broil element, but, because you have to leave > the oven
>> door slightly ajar while broiling, its difficult to reach > the sauce and
>> pasta over the roaring heat lpouring out of the open oven door. Using the
>> broiler on traditional ranges can be > frustrating and inconvenient.

>
> 1. Broiling is a second rate way of making bruschetta.
> 2. It's just this range, makes that point, actually, by saying it is
> different from all other electric ranges.
>
>

Well, this seems to apply to at least many and perhaps all of the
KA ovens.

Funny about the bruschetta!

--
Jean B.

Jean B.[_1_] 08-10-2009 07:00 PM

closed door broiling
 
Nancy2 wrote:
> On Oct 8, 8:56 am, Andy > wrote:
>> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
>> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
>> never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.
>>
>> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
>> much! ;-)
>>
>> Andy

>
> "Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? I'm confused.
>
> My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
> anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. My previous ovens
> have always said to do so. I don't know which is correct, but since
> the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
> usually broil with it closed.
>
> N.


Oh come on (speaking through you to Andy)! You don't have much
experience with electric ovens, I guess. EVERY electric oven I
have had before this one had open-door broiling. That is the
norm. (My KA is aberrant and despicable in this regard.) And I
never burnt out an element.

--
Jean B.

Nancy2 08-10-2009 08:19 PM

closed door broiling
 

> Oh come on (speaking through you to Andy)! *You don't have much
> experience with electric ovens, I guess. *EVERY electric oven I
> have had before this one had open-door broiling. *That is the
> norm. *(My KA is aberrant and despicable in this regard.) *And I
> never burnt out an element.
>
> --
> Jean B.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -



So have mine, Jean - but since the new Westinghouse doesn't say
specifically to broil with the door open a crack, I don't do it. If
they want people to crack the door while broiling, they will put it in
big IMPORTANT letters in the directions.

N.

brooklyn1 08-10-2009 08:21 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Thu, 08 Oct 2009 14:00:04 -0400, "Jean B." > wrote:

>Nancy2 wrote:
>> On Oct 8, 8:56 am, Andy > wrote:
>>> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
>>> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
>>> never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.
>>>
>>> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
>>> much! ;-)
>>>
>>> Andy

>>
>> "Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? I'm confused.
>>
>> My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
>> anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. My previous ovens
>> have always said to do so. I don't know which is correct, but since
>> the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
>> usually broil with it closed.
>>
>> N.

>
>Oh come on (speaking through you to Andy)! You don't have much
>experience with electric ovens, I guess. EVERY electric oven I
>have had before this one had open-door broiling. That is the
>norm. (My KA is aberrant and despicable in this regard.) And I
>never burnt out an element.


Even gas ovens require the door be cracked open when broiling.

Do you actually believe she's telling the truth... do you actually
believe her stove's owner's manual doesn't indicate to leave the oven
door cracked open in the *detent*? Even a lying dingbat will know
five minutes after putting food under the broiler that something is
terribly wrong if they didn't leave the door cracked open... even if
they can't read... the entire house will fill with smoke, the
neighbors will call 911.

I don't give a rat's B-hind what kinda cooking appliance, even a
toaster oven, when broiling the door must be cracked open.

Go he
http://www.white-westinghouse.com/do...06KW_om_en.pdf

Scroll to pg. 12.
Read broiling instructions.
For those who cannot read... THERE'S A ****ING PICTURE!!! LOL LOL LOL
Even reminds again in the Troubleshooting section. hehehe

Friggin' LYING imbeciles... the most cooking they do is bowl o'
cornflakes.

Ahahahahahahahahahahahaha. . . .

Nancy2 08-10-2009 08:23 PM

closed door broiling
 
I've never seen a toaster
> oven that toasts bread very well, because they only toast one side at
> a time, and I've never seen one where one can set the degree of
> doneness... I know of no toaster oven that's worthwhile having for any
> reason whatsoever. *Anytime I'm in a kitchen where there is a toaster
> oven present I know that nobody cooks there.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -


My toaster-oven toasts both sides simultaneously (by means of a
reflective surface on the inside top) and the degree of toasting
(browning) can be infinitely adjustable with the dial.

I use my toaster oven for toasting bread and for baking frozen
prepared foods, like crispy French fries. It's fast, easy, accurate,
and doesn't mess up any appliance or my stove top, which is really
nice when it's just one person's portion.

N.

Nancy2 08-10-2009 08:29 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Oct 8, 2:15*pm, Wayne Boatwright >
wrote:
> On Thu 08 Oct 2009 11:00:04a, Jean B. told us...
>
>
>
>
>
> > Nancy2 wrote:
> >> On Oct 8, 8:56 am, Andy > wrote:
> >>> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
> >>> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor
> >>> constantly will never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp
> >>> setting.

>
> >>> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos,
> >>> not so much! ;-)

>
> >>> Andy

>
> >> "Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? *I'm confused.

>
> >> My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
> >> anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. *My previous ovens
> >> have always said to do so. *I don't know which is correct, but since
> >> the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
> >> usually broil with it closed.

>
> >> N.

>
> > Oh come on (speaking through you to Andy)! *You don't have much
> > experience with electric ovens, I guess. *EVERY electric oven I
> > have had before this one had open-door broiling. *That is the
> > norm. *(My KA is aberrant and despicable in this regard.) *And I
> > never burnt out an element.

>
> My Whirlpool range recommends closed door broiling, although it doesn't
> turn off the heating elements if you open the door.
>
> --
>


Oops, my bad - my new oven is a Whirlpool, not Westinghouse - W'house
was my last one.

N.

Nancy2 08-10-2009 08:34 PM

closed door broiling
 
>
> I don't give a rat's B-hind what kinda cooking appliance, even a
> toaster oven, when broiling the door must be cracked open.
>
> Go hehttp://www.white-westinghouse.com/do...06KW_om_en.pdf
>


You're right about Westinghouse - I was wrong about the brand I have -
it's Whirlpool.

Westinghouse was the one I had before I remodeled the kitchen.

N.

Mark Thorson 08-10-2009 08:53 PM

closed door broiling
 
Wayne Boatwright wrote:
>
> My Whirlpool range recommends closed door broiling, although it doesn't
> turn off the heating elements if you open the door.


Does it say why? It might be for some reason
other than the quality of the food it produces.
For example, it might be to avoid smoke stains
on the oven itself.

Jean B.[_1_] 09-10-2009 02:53 AM

closed door broiling
 
Wayne Boatwright wrote:
> On Thu 08 Oct 2009 11:00:04a, Jean B. told us...
>
>> Nancy2 wrote:
>>> On Oct 8, 8:56 am, Andy > wrote:
>>>> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
>>>> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor
>>>> constantly will never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp
>>>> setting.
>>>>
>>>> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos,
>>>> not so much! ;-)
>>>>
>>>> Andy
>>> "Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? I'm confused.
>>>
>>> My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
>>> anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. My previous ovens
>>> have always said to do so. I don't know which is correct, but since
>>> the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
>>> usually broil with it closed.
>>>
>>> N.

>> Oh come on (speaking through you to Andy)! You don't have much
>> experience with electric ovens, I guess. EVERY electric oven I
>> have had before this one had open-door broiling. That is the
>> norm. (My KA is aberrant and despicable in this regard.) And I
>> never burnt out an element.
>>

>
> My Whirlpool range recommends closed door broiling, although it doesn't
> turn off the heating elements if you open the door.
>


Unfortunately, the KA doesn't work with the door open.

--
Jean B.

Jean B.[_1_] 09-10-2009 02:54 AM

closed door broiling
 
Nancy2 wrote:
>> Oh come on (speaking through you to Andy)! You don't have much
>> experience with electric ovens, I guess. EVERY electric oven I
>> have had before this one had open-door broiling. That is the
>> norm. (My KA is aberrant and despicable in this regard.) And I
>> never burnt out an element.
>>
>> --
>> Jean B.- Hide quoted text -
>>
>> - Show quoted text -

>
>
> So have mine, Jean - but since the new Westinghouse doesn't say
> specifically to broil with the door open a crack, I don't do it. If
> they want people to crack the door while broiling, they will put it in
> big IMPORTANT letters in the directions.
>
> N.


CAN you broil with it open though?

--
Jean B.

Dan Abel 09-10-2009 03:51 AM

closed door broiling
 
In article >,
"Jean B." > wrote:

> Wayne Boatwright wrote:


> > My Whirlpool range recommends closed door broiling, although it doesn't
> > turn off the heating elements if you open the door.
> >

>
> Unfortunately, the KA doesn't work with the door open.


Well, don't tell the KA people that I told you this, but the stupid
stove has to know somehow whether the door is open or not. If you look
at the door, there may be a little prong that fits into a little hole in
the main part of the stove. When the little prong isn't in the hole,
then it cuts the power. When the little prong is in the hole, it allows
the stove to provide heat. I'm reluctant to suggest sticking something
in that hole, but if you're brave, you could try it. My two concerns
are that whatever you stick in could catch fire, and that if something
that can't catch fire falls inside the hole, it could be an expensive
repair visit to retrieve it. Of course, it could well be that the
little dingus that keeps the door from falling on the floor when you
open the door all the way, also tells the stove that the door is closed
all the way. I sure wouldn't mess with that one.

--
Dan Abel
Petaluma, California USA


Ed Pawlowski 09-10-2009 04:01 AM

closed door broiling
 

"notbob" > wrote in message
...
> On 2009-10-08, Giusi > wrote:
>
>> 1. Broiling is a second rate way of making bruschetta.

>
> What, pray tell, is the first rate way?
>
> nb


You brown the bread in a pan or grill on the stove. Bruschetta has been
round longer than broilers



Omelet[_7_] 09-10-2009 05:15 AM

closed door broiling
 
In article 7>,
Wayne Boatwright > wrote:

> On Thu 08 Oct 2009 11:00:04a, Jean B. told us...
>
> > Nancy2 wrote:
> >> On Oct 8, 8:56 am, Andy > wrote:
> >>> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
> >>> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor
> >>> constantly will never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp
> >>> setting.
> >>>
> >>> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos,
> >>> not so much! ;-)
> >>>
> >>> Andy
> >>
> >> "Never" overstrive, or always overstrive? I'm confused.
> >>
> >> My new electric Westinghouse oven doesn't say in the directions
> >> anywhere, to leave the door open during broiling. My previous ovens
> >> have always said to do so. I don't know which is correct, but since
> >> the direction booklet doesn't say to leave the door open a crack, I
> >> usually broil with it closed.
> >>
> >> N.

> >
> > Oh come on (speaking through you to Andy)! You don't have much
> > experience with electric ovens, I guess. EVERY electric oven I
> > have had before this one had open-door broiling. That is the
> > norm. (My KA is aberrant and despicable in this regard.) And I
> > never burnt out an element.
> >

>
> My Whirlpool range recommends closed door broiling, although it doesn't
> turn off the heating elements if you open the door.


I have a GE. We always closed the door when broiling. Why leave it open?
--
Peace! Om

"Human nature seems to be to control other people until they put their foot down."
--Steve Rothstein

Web Albums: <http://picasaweb.google.com/home?tab=mq>

Subscribe:


Steve Pope 09-10-2009 05:17 AM

closed door broiling
 
Omelet > wrote:

>I have a GE. We always closed the door when broiling. Why leave it open?


So you can watch the stuff bubble and broil and take it out
at the exact right time?

Actually, I usually broil things in the toaster oven these days...
the broiler section of the main oven is too down low to the
floor to be convenient (at my older, less flexible age).

Steve

Steve Pope 09-10-2009 05:43 AM

closed door broiling
 
Wayne Boatwright > wrote:

>On Thu 08 Oct 2009 09:17:40p, Steve Pope told us...


>> Actually, I usually broil things in the toaster oven these days...
>> the broiler section of the main oven is too down low to the
>> floor to be convenient (at my older, less flexible age).


>Is yours a gas broiler in the "drawer" below the oven? I remember my
>parents having a couple of gas ranges like that. They weren't terribly
>convenient.


Yep, that's right. The stove is a "Spark". I have no idea
how old it is. Somewhere between 50 and 90 years I would hazard
a guess.

It's a good unit -- a little small, but the oven's even-ness of
temperature and humidity are just right for a lot of things. The
burners work fine, for standard-output burners. The broiler however
is not too useful.

Steve

Dan Abel 09-10-2009 06:15 AM

closed door broiling
 
In article 0>,
Wayne Boatwright > wrote:

> On Thu 08 Oct 2009 09:17:40p, Steve Pope told us...
>
> > Omelet > wrote:
> >
> >>I have a GE. We always closed the door when broiling. Why leave it open?

> >
> > So you can watch the stuff bubble and broil and take it out
> > at the exact right time?
> >
> > Actually, I usually broil things in the toaster oven these days...
> > the broiler section of the main oven is too down low to the
> > floor to be convenient (at my older, less flexible age).
> >
> > Steve
> >

>
> Is yours a gas broiler in the "drawer" below the oven? I remember my
> parents having a couple of gas ranges like that. They weren't terribly
> convenient.


If you look carefully, you'll discover that the burner for the oven and
the broiler are the same. The flame heats the oven, and if you put food
below it, the food broils. My parents had one like that. I remember my
mother getting down on her knees, but not very often. People just
didn't use the broiler very often, because it was so inconvenient. I
think our first stove was like that. I was very pleased when we got a
new stove and the oven burner and broiler were separate, and the broiler
was on the top of the oven. We used the broiler much more often.

Obviously, it's much cheaper to just have one burner that is both the
oven burner and the broiler.

--
Dan Abel
Petaluma, California USA


dsi1[_9_] 09-10-2009 06:43 AM

closed door broiling
 
Andy wrote:
> Jean B. said...
>
>> Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? Whatever it is, it is
>> awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. (And I will make
>> sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)

>
>
> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
> never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.
>
> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
> much! ;-)
>
> Andy


The reason folks used to broil with the oven door open was to defeat the
thermostat and keep the heating element or the gas from cycling off.
Paradoxically, the only way to get the radiant heat output of the oven
high enough, is by keeping the temperature inside the oven low.

My thinking is that most modern ovens can broil with the door closed. If
the oven cycles off, you will have to broil with the door open.
Otherwise, don't worry about it.

Omelet[_7_] 09-10-2009 07:30 AM

closed door broiling
 
In article >,
(Steve Pope) wrote:

> Omelet > wrote:
>
> >I have a GE. We always closed the door when broiling. Why leave it open?

>
> So you can watch the stuff bubble and broil and take it out
> at the exact right time?
>
> Actually, I usually broil things in the toaster oven these days...
> the broiler section of the main oven is too down low to the
> floor to be convenient (at my older, less flexible age).
>
> Steve


Now that dad has finally ditched the coffee maker, I actually have room
on my counter top for a toaster oven.

Now I just have to choose one... :-)
--
Peace! Om

"Human nature seems to be to control other people until they put their foot down."
--Steve Rothstein

Web Albums: <http://picasaweb.google.com/home?tab=mq>

Subscribe:


Giusi 09-10-2009 08:09 AM

closed door broiling
 

"notbob" ha scritto nel messaggio
Giusi wrote:
>

You should grill only the top side that gets scraped with garlic.
>
> You mean I can't have my chèvre with dried tomatoes and fresh basil over
> prosciutto browned? ;)


The bruschetta is the grilled bread with garlic, oil and salt. What you put
on top of that is your business. How you want that stuff to be is also your
business.

The grilling one side is because it is supposed to be made of stale bread.
It can shatter too easily if both sides are grilled. In restaurants they
may not wait for the stale and therefore may grill both sides, but then we
know they aren't the same as mom, don't we?



Giusi 09-10-2009 08:11 AM

closed door broiling
 

"ViLco" ha scritto nel messaggio
> Giusi wrote:
>
>> Grill on one side over open flame. We have these cheap little> metal>>
>> things we use on a gas burner or do them in the FP or on a grill.
>> You should grill only the top side that gets scraped with garlic.

>
> Once I raised a quasi - riot in a tuscan town, Capalbio, by asking> in a
> pub if bruschette had to be grilled only on one side or both,> everyone
> had theyr version. Me, for example, brown both the sides of> the bread but
> add garlic, salt and oil only on one.


Do you use stale bread or any you come across? Do you use the cheap little
Italian toaster? Which oil do you prefer? Fettunta is a wonderful thing
and all the others are just strivers!



Ed Pawlowski 09-10-2009 10:45 AM

closed door broiling
 

"Jean B." > wrote in message
>
> Unfortunately, the KA doesn't work with the door open.
>


From the KA manual
Before broiling, position rack according to the Broiling Chart. It is

not necessary to preheat the oven before putting food in unless

recommended in the recipe. Position food on grid in the broiler

pan, then place it in the center of the oven rack.

Close the door to ensure proper broiling operation.

Variable Temperature Broiling

Changing the temperature when Variable Temperature Broiling

allows more precise control when cooking. The lower the

temperature, the slower the cooking. Thicker cuts and unevenly

shaped pieces of meat, fish and poultry may cook better at lower

broiling temperatures.

To Use:

1. Close oven door.

2. Press BROIL once for FULL BROIL or twice for CENTER

BROIL.

3. Press the number pads to set a temperature between 300°F

and 500°F (149°C to 260°C).

4. Press START.

The temperature can be changed after this step. Press the

number pads to reset the temperature, then press START.

5. Press OFF when finished.



Ed Pawlowski 09-10-2009 11:01 AM

closed door broiling
 

"Wayne Boatwright" > wrote in message
> Yes, almost all of the early design gas stoves used a shared burner for
> broiler and oven, although there were a few 40" stoves that had a broiler
> compartment next to the oven. My mother O'Keefe & Merritt had the shared
> burner.
>


In the mid 1950's we had a Caloric that had a built in rotisserie on the
side.



brooklyn1 09-10-2009 04:17 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Thu, 8 Oct 2009 23:01:28 -0400, "Ed Pawlowski" >
wrote:

>
>"notbob" > wrote in message
...
>> On 2009-10-08, Giusi > wrote:
>>
>>> 1. Broiling is a second rate way of making bruschetta.

>>
>> What, pray tell, is the first rate way?
>>
>> nb

>
>You brown the bread in a pan or grill on the stove. Bruschetta has been
>round longer than broilers
>

Broiling means to cook with direct flame... broiling is the oldest
form of cooking... folks have been broiling since long before the
invention of the pot/pan. Hanging a hunk of meat on the end of a
stick over an open fire is broiling. Cooking on an outdoor grill is
broiling. Folks have been broiling since long, LONG before there was
bread. But folks have been broiling/toasting bread long before there
were appliances.

Bruschetta is what to do with the glut of picked over/left over bread
at restaurants, Italian eateries especially, since it's customery that
they serve excessive bread with every meal... order a pizza and still
the big basket of bread arrives... don't for one second think your
local guido joint tosses patron's left over bread in the trash... they
turn it into crumbs for breading cutlets, eggplant, and filling out
meataballes. They have so much left over bread that's cleared off
tables that the two Italian restaurants near me will give me all I
want to feed critters anytime I ask... they are supposed to toss it in
the dumpster out back but they don't, instead it's held in the same
large corrogated cartons the bread arrived in from the bakery... it's
made into brushetta and garlic bread. All restaurants do this. Even
the bread crumbs you buy at the market in those cardboard cylinders is
made from bread swept up at commercial bakeries... do yoose really
think they bake bread for the explicit purpose of making into
crumbs... yoose believe that I have a bridge yoose wanna buy. Crumbs
is another use for my meat grinder... I don't want mystery crumbs. Do
you relize that buying packaged bread crumbs is a recent innovation,
started like 50 years ago... back than all homemakers made ther own
crumbs... usta bring their own stale bread to the butcher shop too, to
push the last of the meat through... back then there was no preground
mystery meat. Yoose do realize there was a time before canned dog
food, not all that long ago.... what folks feed their pets is cleaner
than preground.


brooklyn1 09-10-2009 04:21 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Fri, 9 Oct 2009 04:17:40 +0000 (UTC), (Steve
Pope) wrote:

>Omelet > wrote:
>
>>I have a GE. We always closed the door when broiling. Why leave it open?

>
>So you can watch the stuff bubble and broil and take it out
>at the exact right time?
>
>Actually, I usually broil things in the toaster oven these days...
>the broiler section of the main oven is too down low to the
>floor to be convenient (at my older, less flexible age).


Your stove is like 50 years old... don't you think it time you
moderenzed. Still those old bottom broilers had a door detent.

>Steve


Tracy[_2_] 09-10-2009 04:33 PM

closed door broiling
 


brooklyn1 wrote:
> On Fri, 9 Oct 2009 04:17:40 +0000 (UTC), (Steve
> Pope) wrote:
>
>> Omelet > wrote:
>>
>>> I have a GE. We always closed the door when broiling. Why leave it open?

>> So you can watch the stuff bubble and broil and take it out
>> at the exact right time?
>>
>> Actually, I usually broil things in the toaster oven these days...
>> the broiler section of the main oven is too down low to the
>> floor to be convenient (at my older, less flexible age).

>
> Your stove is like 50 years old... don't you think it time you
> moderenzed. Still those old bottom broilers had a door detent.
>
>> Steve


When I was shopping for a new gas stove I realized that the only way
to avoid a broiler in the drawer type stove was to get a self
cleaning stove. I really, really dislike the broiler in the drawer.
When we bought our house this spring, we knew we needed to buy a new
stove because this is what was the

http://tinypic.com/r/nwy3hl/4

Tracy

brooklyn1 09-10-2009 04:33 PM

closed door broiling
 
Omelet > wrote:
>
> I have a GE. We always closed the door when broiling. Why leave it open?


Obviously you never read the owner's manual.

Your house is probably so filthy that the smoke produced doesn't
bother you... and so you don't create a grease fire that burns down
your house... although would be no great loss with an abode so filthy
that it really should be condemned.

The reason that stoves with bottom drawer broilers aren't produced
anymore is house fires.

brooklyn1 09-10-2009 04:43 PM

closed door broiling
 
On Thu, 08 Oct 2009 19:43:44 -1000, dsi1 > wrote:

>Andy wrote:
>> Jean B. said...
>>
>>> Maybe this is mainly a KitchenAid thing? Whatever it is, it is
>>> awful, and I will never get a KA oven again. (And I will make
>>> sure anything else I get operates in the correct manner!!!!)

>>
>>
>> When temperature sensors measure heat, leaving an oven door open is a
>> surefire way to burn out the electric elements as the sensor constantly will
>> never "over-strive" to achieve the requested temp setting.
>>
>> That should've been plainly obvious to all the rfc brainiacs. Bozos, not so
>> much! ;-)
>>
>> Andy

>
>The reason folks used to broil with the oven door open was to defeat the
>thermostat and keep the heating element or the gas from cycling off.


When in broil mode the thermostat is switched off.

>Paradoxically, the only way to get the radiant heat output of the oven
>high enough, is by keeping the temperature inside the oven low.
>
>My thinking is that most modern ovens can broil with the door closed. If
>the oven cycles off, you will have to broil with the door open.
>Otherwise, don't worry about it.


Didja know you don't have any thinking, you're an idiot.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:19 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FoodBanter