|
roast bones before making beef broth?
Why is it necessary to roast the bones before
making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. |
roast bones before making beef broth?
|
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 16:44:36 -0400, Richard McBeef
> wrote: >Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? >What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. Not 'Necessary' but possibly desirable. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maillard_reaction The jury's out regarding the best way forward Some say 'Roast', Some Say 'Don't Roast' and some say 'Roast some & don't roast the rest'. YMMV. For what it's worth, to date, I've roasted bones for all of my stock but the result tends to be a bit sweet. Must get around to trying the other way. Regards JonH |
roast bones before making beef broth?
"Richard McBeef" > wrote in message ... > Why is it necessary to roast the bones before > making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? > What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. roast to make brown stock don't roast to make white stock |
roast bones before making beef broth?
Richard McBeef wrote:
> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before > making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? > What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. Brings out the flavour of the marrow in the bones; roasted bones have more of an intense taste than raw bones. Just my opinion, of course. But it's one reason I insist on a bone-in standing rib roast when I want to prepare prime rib. The other reason is, if you slice the meat off the (cooked) roast just right, you have nice meaty beef ribs for BBQ. Jill |
roast bones before making beef broth?
>Richard McBeef wrote: >> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? >> What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. Not to detract from the question and the answers in this thread..but has no one noticed that the poster is using the name of the fictional person in the writings of the VT killer? This poster also posted using the name of the killer. I find this odd..and maybe it is just me, but I also find it a bit disturbing to say the least. Christine |
roast bones before making beef broth?
"Christine Dabney" > wrote >>Richard McBeef wrote: >>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? >>> What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. > > Not to detract from the question and the answers in this thread..but > has no one noticed that the poster is using the name of the fictional > person in the writings of the VT killer? This poster also posted > using the name of the killer. I find this odd..and maybe it is just > me, but I also find it a bit disturbing to say the least. Huh. I hadn't noticed. What a jerk. nancy |
roast bones before making beef broth?
Christine Dabney wrote:
>> Richard McBeef wrote: >>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. > > Not to detract from the question and the answers in this thread..but > has no one noticed that the poster is using the name of the fictional > person in the writings of the VT killer? This poster also posted > using the name of the killer. I find this odd..and maybe it is just > me, but I also find it a bit disturbing to say the least. > > Christine I didn't see that in my original repy and I still don't see it here. Reading other replies I now see it. What an asshole! Jill |
roast bones before making beef broth?
"jmcquown" > wrote in message ... > Richard McBeef wrote: > > Why is it necessary to roast the bones before > > making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? > > What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. > > > In article >, > > You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech by using > this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK DICKHEAD. And you > may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the FBI in Quantico. See how you > feel about joking around now, asshole. Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading the posts. Sick *******, indeed. Paul |
roast bones before making beef broth?
Richard McBeef wrote:
> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before > making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? Carmelization adds to the flavor. > What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. No flavor? |
roast bones before making beef broth?
Paul M. Cook wrote:
> "jmcquown" > wrote in message > ... >> Richard McBeef wrote: >>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >> >>> In article >, >>> >> >> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, asshole. > > Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading > the posts. Sick *******, indeed. > > Paul I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to the FBI. I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even the most tenuous ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being *ass*). Hopefully they will make this "joker's" life miserable for a while. Complicit or not, it's no joking matter. I can't believe some people think this is funny, I really can't. It's a tragedy. And this dillhole comes on here using that name and thinks it's funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. Jill |
roast bones before making beef broth?
jmcquown wrote:
> Paul M. Cook wrote: >> "jmcquown" > wrote in message >> ... >>> Richard McBeef wrote: >>>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >>>> In article >, >>>> >>> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >>> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >>> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >>> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, asshole. >> Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading >> the posts. Sick *******, indeed. >> >> Paul > > I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to the FBI. > I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even the most tenuous > ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being *ass*). Hopefully they > will make this "joker's" life miserable for a while. Complicit or not, it's > no joking matter. I can't believe some people think this is funny, I really > can't. It's a tragedy. And this dillhole comes on here using that name and > thinks it's funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he > tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. Jokes even in bad taste are not a crime. Fantasizing lengthy false imprisonment is odd. Definitely unamerican! Do you really think the fbi will investigate every bad joke related to this? If anything you have self identified yourself to the authorities as a bit dull. |
roast bones before making beef broth?
jmcquown wrote:
> Richard McBeef wrote: >> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? >> What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. > >> In article >, > > You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech by using > this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK DICKHEAD. And you > may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the FBI in Quantico. See how you > feel about joking around now, asshole. Chill out. Just a joke. Fortunately, the fbi only hires smart people and they will ignore your crank emails. Do some googling. Many people have made some jokes about this already. For example, did you see the fake blog done by, I believe, another vt student? Anyway, I suppose I guess it is too soon for this sort of thing. |
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Apr 18, 8:51 pm, Beer Drinking Dog > wrote:
> Richard McBeef wrote: > > Why is it necessary to roast the bones before > > making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? > > Carmelization adds to the flavor. > > > What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. > > No flavor? Some pros(I'm not one of them)take a brush and brush bones with honey before roasting. Extra brown carmelized sugar; darker brown stock... |
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Apr 18, 9:37 pm, "jmcquown" > wrote:
> Paul M. Cook wrote: > > "jmcquown" > wrote in message > ... > >> Richard McBeef wrote: > >>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before > >>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting > >>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. > > >>> In article >, > >>> > > >> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech > >> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK > >> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the > >> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, asshole. > > > Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading > > the posts. Sick *******, indeed. > > > Paul > > I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to the FBI. > I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even the most tenuous > ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being *ass*). Hopefully they > will make this "joker's" life miserable for a while. Complicit or not, it's > no joking matter. I can't believe some people think this is funny, I really > can't. It's a tragedy. And this dillhole comes on here using that name and > thinks it's funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he > tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. > > Jill- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text - It's not funny but why bother even stewing about this? |
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 21:00:49 GMT, wrote:
>On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 16:44:36 -0400, Richard McBeef > wrote: > >>Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? >>What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. > >Not 'Necessary' but possibly desirable. > >http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maillard_reaction > >The jury's out regarding the best way forward Some say 'Roast', Some >Say 'Don't Roast' and some say 'Roast some & don't roast the rest'. > >YMMV. For what it's worth, to date, I've roasted bones for all of my >stock but the result tends to be a bit sweet. Must get around to >trying the other way. > Bone roasting won't affect the sweetness of your stock. Onions and carrots do that. -- See return address to reply by email |
roast bones before making beef broth?
CliffMacgillivray wrote:
> jmcquown wrote: >> Paul M. Cook wrote: >>> "jmcquown" > wrote in message >>> ... >>>> Richard McBeef wrote: >>>>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>>>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>>>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >>>>> In article >, >>>>> >>>> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >>>> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >>>> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >>>> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, >>>> asshole. >>> Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading >>> the posts. Sick *******, indeed. >>> >>> Paul >> >> I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to >> the FBI. I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even >> the most tenuous ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being >> *ass*). Hopefully they will make this "joker's" life miserable for >> a while. Complicit or not, it's no joking matter. I can't believe >> some people think this is funny, I really can't. It's a tragedy. >> And this dillhole comes on here using that name and thinks it's >> funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he >> tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. > Jokes even in bad taste are not a crime. Fantasizing lengthy false > imprisonment is odd. Definitely unamerican! > Do you really think the fbi will investigate every bad joke related to > this? If anything you have self identified yourself to the authorities > as a bit dull. YOU are an asshole and this is in terribly bad taste. Just wait until the FBI knocks on your door, idiot. If you want to be taken seriously you won't post using such bad taste in the wake of a terrible tragedy. Frankly, I'm surprised you came back here. |
roast bones before making beef broth?
Richard McBeef wrote:
> jmcquown wrote: >> Richard McBeef wrote: >>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >> >>> In article >, >>> >> >> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, asshole. > Chill out. Just a joke. Fortunately, the fbi only hires smart people > and they will ignore your crank emails. > Do some googling. Many people have made some jokes about this already. > For example, did you see the fake blog done by, I believe, another vt > student? > Anyway, I suppose I guess it is too soon for this sort of thing. IDIOT students are not welcome here. Really. We don't often scorn people who have legitimate inquiries but yours is just in bad taste at this point. It's obvious you don't give a shit about what happened; you think it's all a joke. "All in good fun." **** off. Go find a cookbook. Ask your mom. Whatever. Just go the hell away from here, you tasteless, tactless piece of shit. |
roast bones before making beef broth?
jmcquown wrote:
> CliffMacgillivray wrote: >> jmcquown wrote: >>> Paul M. Cook wrote: >>>> "jmcquown" > wrote in message >>>> ... >>>>> Richard McBeef wrote: >>>>>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>>>>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>>>>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >>>>>> In article >, >>>>>> >>>>> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >>>>> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >>>>> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >>>>> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, >>>>> asshole. >>>> Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading >>>> the posts. Sick *******, indeed. >>>> >>>> Paul >>> I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to >>> the FBI. I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even >>> the most tenuous ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being >>> *ass*). Hopefully they will make this "joker's" life miserable for >>> a while. Complicit or not, it's no joking matter. I can't believe >>> some people think this is funny, I really can't. It's a tragedy. >>> And this dillhole comes on here using that name and thinks it's >>> funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he >>> tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. >> Jokes even in bad taste are not a crime. Fantasizing lengthy false >> imprisonment is odd. Definitely unamerican! >> Do you really think the fbi will investigate every bad joke related to >> this? If anything you have self identified yourself to the authorities >> as a bit dull. > > YOU are an asshole and this is in terribly bad taste. Just wait until the > FBI knocks on your door, idiot. If you want to be taken seriously you won't > post using such bad taste in the wake of a terrible tragedy. Frankly, I'm > surprised you came back here. Look, your famous! http://www.whofailedtoday.com/newbbs...397061#p397061 |
roast bones before making beef broth?
"Richard McBeef" > wrote in message ... > Why is it necessary to roast the bones before > making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? > What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. It makes a very BIG difference in flavor and color Dimitri http://www.landfood.ubc.ca/courses/f...brown_prin.htm Maillard Reaction Introduction Maillard reaction is a non-enzymatic browning reaction, caused by the condensation of an amino group and a reducing compound, resulting complex changes in biological and food system. This reaction was described for the first time by Louis Maillard in 1912. Maillard reaction occurs when virtually all foods are heated, and also occurs during storage. Most of the effect of Maillard reaction, including the caramel aromas and golden brown colors, are desirable. Nevertheless, some of the effect of Maillard reaction, including foods darkness and off-flavor development, are undesirable. Maillard Reaction Products * Aroma and Flavor Maillard-derived aromas are extremely complex and many components are formed in trace amounts by side-reactions and obscure pathways. The deoxyosones are considered to be primary source of aroma volatile compounds. Deoxyosones undergo cyclization/dehydration to produce flavor important furan derivatives and different types of furans are formed depending in osone structure. The aroma profile also varies with the temperature and time of heating. At any given temperature-time combination, a unique aroma, which is not likely to be reproduced at any other combination of heating conditions, is produced. The formation of a specific flavor may require the simultaneous generation of 100 or 200 individual chemicals in the proper concentration and delicate balance. A large number and wide variety of flavor and aroma compounds are formed via the Maillard reaction. Moreover, reactant composition, environment and processing could influence the reaction. * Color The development of color is an extremely important feature of the Maillard reaction but relatively little is known about the chemical nature of the compounds responsible. There are both good and bad sides of the Maillard reaction for color development. Color development in meats and bread baking is desirable while the browning of dry milk or dehydrated products is undesirable. |
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Thu, 19 Apr 2007 07:05:07 -0700, sf wrote:
>On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 21:00:49 GMT, wrote: > >>On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 16:44:36 -0400, Richard McBeef > wrote: >> >>>Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>>making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting has? >>>What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >> >>Not 'Necessary' but possibly desirable. >> >>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maillard_reaction >> >>The jury's out regarding the best way forward Some say 'Roast', Some >>Say 'Don't Roast' and some say 'Roast some & don't roast the rest'. >> >>YMMV. For what it's worth, to date, I've roasted bones for all of my >>stock but the result tends to be a bit sweet. Must get around to >>trying the other way. >> >Bone roasting won't affect the sweetness of your stock. Onions and >carrots do that. Not sure that I agree, but I'm prepared to be convinced. My palate is pretty jaded but it sounds like a 'Fair Test' is required. I will acquire fresh bones and run a pan of each in parallel and will report back in due course. Regards JonH |
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 20:37:40 -0500, "jmcquown"
> wrote: >Paul M. Cook wrote: >> "jmcquown" > wrote in message >> ... >>> Richard McBeef wrote: >>>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >>> >>>> In article >, >>>> >>> >>> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >>> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >>> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >>> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, asshole. >> >> Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading >> the posts. Sick *******, indeed. >> >> Paul > >I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to the FBI. >I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even the most tenuous >ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being *ass*). Hopefully they >will make this "joker's" life miserable for a while. Complicit or not, it's >no joking matter. I can't believe some people think this is funny, I really >can't. It's a tragedy. And this dillhole comes on here using that name and >thinks it's funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he >tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. > >Jill > jeez, do you sic the f.b.i. on everyone who upsets you? (i'm sure they'll get right on it.) i better watch my p's and q's. your pal, (name withheld upon request) |
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Thu, 19 Apr 2007 09:37:39 -0400, CliffMacgillivray
> wrote: >jmcquown wrote: >> Paul M. Cook wrote: >>> "jmcquown" > wrote in message >>> ... >>>> Richard McBeef wrote: >>>>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>>>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>>>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >>>>> In article >, >>>>> >>>> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >>>> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >>>> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >>>> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, asshole. >>> Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading >>> the posts. Sick *******, indeed. >>> >>> Paul >> >> I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to the FBI. >> I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even the most tenuous >> ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being *ass*). Hopefully they >> will make this "joker's" life miserable for a while. Complicit or not, it's >> no joking matter. I can't believe some people think this is funny, I really >> can't. It's a tragedy. And this dillhole comes on here using that name and >> thinks it's funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he >> tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. >Jokes even in bad taste are not a crime. Fantasizing lengthy false >imprisonment is odd. Definitely unamerican! >Do you really think the fbi will investigate every bad joke related to >this? If anything you have self identified yourself to the authorities >as a bit dull. and if they find out she likes korean food, she's cooked. your pal, blake |
roast bones before making beef broth?
On Thu, 19 Apr 2007 09:56:43 -0500, "jmcquown"
> wrote: >CliffMacgillivray wrote: >> jmcquown wrote: >>> Paul M. Cook wrote: >>>> "jmcquown" > wrote in message >>>> ... >>>>> Richard McBeef wrote: >>>>>> Why is it necessary to roast the bones before >>>>>> making a beef broth? I am curious as to what effect the roasting >>>>>> has? What would the difference be if the roasting were not done. >>>>>> In article >, >>>>>> >>>>> You're making fun of the assassinations of the students at V. Tech >>>>> by using this ID?! What kind of a loser asshole are you?! PLONK >>>>> DICKHEAD. And you may be complicit so I'm forwarding this to the >>>>> FBI in Quantico. See how you feel about joking around now, >>>>> asshole. >>>> Kudos for spotting that. I almost replied to the SOB before reading >>>> the posts. Sick *******, indeed. >>>> >>>> Paul >>> >>> I can't take credit for first spotting it, but I DID report him to >>> the FBI. I imagine they want to track and question anyone with even >>> the most tenuous ties to this V. Tech assassin (keyword there being >>> *ass*). Hopefully they will make this "joker's" life miserable for >>> a while. Complicit or not, it's no joking matter. I can't believe >>> some people think this is funny, I really can't. It's a tragedy. >>> And this dillhole comes on here using that name and thinks it's >>> funny? May they screw up the next 5 years of his life while he >>> tries to explain his way out of it, that's what I hope for. >> Jokes even in bad taste are not a crime. Fantasizing lengthy false >> imprisonment is odd. Definitely unamerican! >> Do you really think the fbi will investigate every bad joke related to >> this? If anything you have self identified yourself to the authorities >> as a bit dull. > >YOU are an asshole and this is in terribly bad taste. Just wait until the >FBI knocks on your door, idiot. If you want to be taken seriously you won't >post using such bad taste in the wake of a terrible tragedy. Frankly, I'm >surprised you came back here. > why **** around with the f.b.i.? report him to the homeland security people, and they can squirrel his ass away in gitmo. he'll laugh out of the other side of his mouth then. your pal, alberto |
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:57 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FoodBanter