View Single Post
  #57 (permalink)   Report Post  
Rudy Canoza
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Rupert wrote:

>
> Rudy Canoza wrote:
>
>>Rupert wrote:
>>
>>
>>>Rudy Canoza wrote:
>>>
>>>
wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>>The main point of veganism is to boycott factory-farming, which causes
>>>>>animals to lead miserable lives.
>>>>>
>>>>>The animals who live on factory farms have to be fed with plant
>>>>>products, the production of which will cause the death of wildlife.
>>>>>Animal products are an inefficient use of land,
>>>>
>>>>False. You have no useful definition of efficiency to
>>>>support that claim. It's purely a value judgment, not
>>>>a reasoned finding.
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>Well, more land is required to produce a given quantity of animal
>>>protein than same quantity of plant protein.

>>
>>So what? Minimizing land use per unit of nutrient
>>produced is not the measure of efficiency at all.
>>We're talking, or should be, about *economic*
>>efficiency of resource use, not physical efficiency.
>>

>
>
> Why?


Because it's the only kind that's meaningful for human
choice. Why do you think crude physical efficiency is
relevant? Who cares how much total land is used? Why
*would* anyone care?