FoodBanter.com

FoodBanter.com (https://www.foodbanter.com/)
-   Wine (https://www.foodbanter.com/wine/)
-   -   merlot bloody merlot (https://www.foodbanter.com/wine/98783-merlot-bloody-merlot.html)

Tim S Roberts 15-08-2006 01:06 AM

merlot bloody merlot
 
I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
wake the next morning with a headache.

Now, the only problem with this is that I can't believe the chemical
composition of a merlot is significantly different from any other red. So
is it just coincidence? Is it psychological? Or are merlots really
different for some reason? And has anyone else experienced anything
similar?

Tim



UC[_1_] 15-08-2006 01:13 AM

merlot bloody merlot
 

Tim S Roberts wrote:
> I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
> and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
> wake the next morning with a headache.
>
> Now, the only problem with this is that I can't believe the chemical
> composition of a merlot is significantly different from any other red. So
> is it just coincidence? Is it psychological? Or are merlots really
> different for some reason? And has anyone else experienced anything
> similar?
>
> Tim


Try something made from Sangiovese.


Hunt 15-08-2006 02:41 AM

merlot bloody merlot
 
In article >, says...
>
>I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
>and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
>wake the next morning with a headache.
>
>Now, the only problem with this is that I can't believe the chemical
>composition of a merlot is significantly different from any other red. So
>is it just coincidence? Is it psychological? Or are merlots really
>different for some reason? And has anyone else experienced anything
>similar?
>
>Tim


I cannot address the compounds in Merlot, or most other wines, for that matter
- Calling Mark Lipton!

However, I experience similar problems with Pinot Noir. I love many examples
of that varietal, from Burg clones, to those of CA and WA/OR. However, with
the same general quantity of PN, as most other wines, reds & whites, I awake
with a headache. I hate it, as I love PN's. I just try and schedule my day a
tad later, if I know I'm doing a PN-tasting, or heading to a favorite FR
restaurant, where the Burgs are likely to flow.

Now, my wife suffers GI problems with most reds, except (as UC stated)
Sangiovese, and Zinfandel. Why this is, is beyond my comprehension. I'm just
offering these antecdotal ruminations to show that you have company, though
maybe not with regards to Merlot. OTOH, I probably do fewer Merlots, than many
other red varietals.

Hunt


miles 15-08-2006 03:51 AM

merlot bloody merlot
 
Tim S Roberts wrote:
> I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
> and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
> wake the next morning with a headache.


I get headaches with wines at times but never seems to be a particular
wine that does it. Reds more so than whites. I used to think it was
sulfites but someone else here pointed out that its whites that should
have higher sulfites.

Easy to solve. Don't drink Merlot! To me it's a rather non-descript
wine lacking much complexity or depth. Theres also a glut of crap
Merlot at least in the USA market because its more or less become a
entry level wine. I have found a few Merlots that are truly great but
its a rarity. In those cases the winemaker broke from the traditional
Merlot style. Its a grape that needs to go back to whats its good for.
Blending!

Ed Rasimus 15-08-2006 01:23 PM

merlot bloody merlot
 
On 14 Aug 2006 17:13:33 -0700, "UC" >
wrote:

>
>Tim S Roberts wrote:
>> I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
>> and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
>> wake the next morning with a headache.
>>
>> Now, the only problem with this is that I can't believe the chemical
>> composition of a merlot is significantly different from any other red. So
>> is it just coincidence? Is it psychological? Or are merlots really
>> different for some reason? And has anyone else experienced anything
>> similar?
>>
>> Tim

>
>Try something made from Sangiovese.


Try addressing the question.

Ed Rasimus
Fighter Pilot (USAF-Ret)
"When Thunder Rolled"
www.thunderchief.org
www.thundertales.blogspot.com

UC[_1_] 15-08-2006 03:57 PM

merlot bloody merlot
 

Ed Rasimus wrote:
> On 14 Aug 2006 17:13:33 -0700, "UC" >
> wrote:
>
> >
> >Tim S Roberts wrote:
> >> I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
> >> and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
> >> wake the next morning with a headache.
> >>
> >> Now, the only problem with this is that I can't believe the chemical
> >> composition of a merlot is significantly different from any other red. So
> >> is it just coincidence? Is it psychological? Or are merlots really
> >> different for some reason? And has anyone else experienced anything
> >> similar?
> >>
> >> Tim

> >
> >Try something made from Sangiovese.

>
> Try addressing the question.


Uhmmmmm....I did!


[email protected] 15-08-2006 05:20 PM

merlot bloody merlot
 

Tim S Roberts wrote:
> I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
> and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
> wake the next morning with a headache.
>
> Now, the only problem with this is that I can't believe the chemical
> composition of a merlot is significantly different from any other red. So
> is it just coincidence? Is it psychological? Or are merlots really
> different for some reason? And has anyone else experienced anything
> similar?


Perhaps, you are head over heels in love with Merlot and you drink more
of it than you usually do with other wines.

Karen


Jon Nadelberg 16-08-2006 11:29 AM

merlot bloody merlot
 
Tim S Roberts wrote:
> I drink a fair amount of wine - chardonnays and blends mainly in the whites,
> and all of the red varieties. BUT, whenever I drink merlots, it seems I
> wake the next morning with a headache.
>
> Now, the only problem with this is that I can't believe the chemical
> composition of a merlot is significantly different from any other red. So
> is it just coincidence? Is it psychological? Or are merlots really
> different for some reason? And has anyone else experienced anything
> similar?
>



A lot of people seem to get headaches from red wine. There are a lot of
articles on the web about it.

Here is one:

http://www.beekmanwine.com/prevtopbd.htm

Try taking an aspirin before drinking your merlot, see if it helps.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:26 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FoodBanter