Oswaldo was in town, a group met at Grand Sichuan St Marks for soup dumplings, chong qing chicken, tea smoked duck, pork and chestnuts, and other assorted dishes, and had a rollicking good time. Surprisingly, we had wine:

The Pink
There was a corked bottle of La Kiuva (Vallee d’Aoste) rose. Damn.

The Bubbly
1996 Chidaine “Almendra” Montlouis Brut
I think I liked a bit more than table. Gentle petillance, apple turnover aromas, long mineral finish. B+

The Dryish Whites

2001 Boxler Sommerberg Riesling (L31E)
I like Boxler, except for pricing and not being totally sure how much sugar I’ll find. This is on drier side, just a whisper of sugar, with fresh fruit and gingery spices. I quite liked. B+

1999 Luneau-Papin “L d’Or” Muscadet
Soft for Muscadet, but nice flavors and good saline minerality. A good match with the cucumbers in scallion sauce. B

2009 Ch. Thebaud Muscadet
A joint project of Marc Ollivier and another vigneron, extended lees aging, I thought this delicious. Full but racy, dense citrus fruit and a mineral bonanza on the finish. A-

The Whites with Some Obvious Sugar
1997 Schmitt-Wagner Longuicher Maximiner Herrenberg Spatlese
Some calls of TCA, but I didn’t get. But not as good as last bottle I had- if it’s corked, under my threshold, but the pit fruit profile seems dull compared to previous showings. B-/C+

2001 Schmitt-Wagner Longuicher Maximiner Herrenberg Auslese
Lime and nectarine, some petrol, good acids, very nice. B+

2001 Muller-Catoir Haardter Mandelring Scheurebe Spatlese
Zippy as hell, honeydew with a squeeze of lime and mint, exotic and long, A-

The Reds
2006 de L’Arlot “Clos des Forets St Georges “ Nuits St Georges 1er
Open, giving, fleshy with flab (good acids for a 2006), red fruits with some sandalwood and spice, good length, delighted to see I own a couple of these. B+/A-

2008 Digioia-Royer “Les Fremieres- VV” Chambolle Musigny
Apparently tight at first, it opened a bit. Solid, some tannin, nice but not compelling. B

1955 Ch. Giscours (Margaux) from 375
Jay brought knowing Oswaldo’s birthyear. What a great showing for a half bottle. Pretty red berry fruits, cigarbox, truffly mushroom notes. Good length, holds up well in decanter for hours, delicious. A-

1974 Charles Krug “Vintage Selection” Cabernet Sauvignon
Double decanted before I traveled to city. I had only stood up one day, lots of sediment, but I don’t think the decanting hurt. Nice but tired bottle, tannins fully resolved, low acid, some interest but I’ve had better bottles of this (and of course the F1 is better). B-

1997 Montevertine “Il Sodaccio”
This was declared corked, but again apparently well under my threshold. Fleshy, ripe, but some nice black cherry fruit, I liked a bottle last week a bit more. B/B-

1999 Carlo Giacosa “Narin” Barbaresco
Tannic, fairly ripe with a edge of heat (14%), a tad brutish, but hey it was cheap. B-

2010 Breton Franc de Pied Bourgueil
Very young, I didn’t give this the attention it deserved and didn’t write down anything, but liked.

Fun night, but best part was the company.


Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.

On 5/25/2012 10:38 AM, DaleW wrote:
> Oswaldo was in town, a group met at Grand Sichuan St Marks for soup dumplings, chong qing chicken, tea smoked duck, pork and chestnuts, and other assorted dishes, and had a rollicking good time. Surprisingly, we had wine:
>
> The Pink
> There was a corked bottle of La Kiuva (Vallee d’Aoste) rose. Damn.
>
> The Bubbly
> 1996 Chidaine “Almendra” Montlouis Brut
> I think I liked a bit more than table. Gentle petillance, apple turnover aromas, long mineral finish. B+
>
> The Dryish Whites
>
> 2001 Boxler Sommerberg Riesling (L31E)
> I like Boxler, except for pricing and not being totally sure how much sugar I’ll find. This is on drier side, just a whisper of sugar, with fresh fruit and gingery spices. I quite liked. B+
>
> 1999 Luneau-Papin “L d’Or” Muscadet
> Soft for Muscadet, but nice flavors and good saline minerality. A good match with the cucumbers in scallion sauce. B
>
> 2009 Ch. Thebaud Muscadet
> A joint project of Marc Ollivier and another vigneron, extended lees aging, I thought this delicious. Full but racy, dense citrus fruit and a mineral bonanza on the finish. A-
>
> The Whites with Some Obvious Sugar
> 1997 Schmitt-Wagner Longuicher Maximiner Herrenberg Spatlese
> Some calls of TCA, but I didn’t get. But not as good as last bottle I had- if it’s corked, under my threshold, but the pit fruit profile seems dull compared to previous showings. B-/C+
>
> 2001 Schmitt-Wagner Longuicher Maximiner Herrenberg Auslese
> Lime and nectarine, some petrol, good acids, very nice. B+
>
> 2001 Muller-Catoir Haardter Mandelring Scheurebe Spatlese
> Zippy as hell, honeydew with a squeeze of lime and mint, exotic and long, A-
>
> The Reds
> 2006 de L’Arlot “Clos des Forets St Georges “ Nuits St Georges 1er
> Open, giving, fleshy with flab (good acids for a 2006), red fruits with some sandalwood and spice, good length, delighted to see I own a couple of these. B+/A-
>
> 2008 Digioia-Royer “Les Fremieres- VV” Chambolle Musigny
> Apparently tight at first, it opened a bit. Solid, some tannin, nice but not compelling. B
>
> 1955 Ch. Giscours (Margaux) from 375
> Jay brought knowing Oswaldo’s birthyear. What a great showing for a half bottle. Pretty red berry fruits, cigarbox, truffly mushroom notes. Good length, holds up well in decanter for hours, delicious. A-
>
> 1974 Charles Krug “Vintage Selection” Cabernet Sauvignon
> Double decanted before I traveled to city. I had only stood up one day, lots of sediment, but I don’t think the decanting hurt. Nice but tired bottle, tannins fully resolved, low acid, some interest but I’ve had better bottles of this (and of course the F1 is better). B-
>
> 1997 Montevertine “Il Sodaccio”
> This was declared corked, but again apparently well under my threshold. Fleshy, ripe, but some nice black cherry fruit, I liked a bottle last week a bit more. B/B-
>
> 1999 Carlo Giacosa “Narin” Barbaresco
> Tannic, fairly ripe with a edge of heat (14%), a tad brutish, but hey it was cheap. B-
>
> 2010 Breton Franc de Pied Bourgueil
> Very young, I didn’t give this the attention it deserved and didn’t write down anything, but liked.
>
> Fun night, but best part was the company.
>
>
> Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.

Gawd, how many of you were there?

--
Jim Silverton (Potomac, MD)

Extraneous "not" in Reply To.