FoodBanter.com

FoodBanter.com (https://www.foodbanter.com/)
-   General Cooking (https://www.foodbanter.com/general-cooking/)
-   -   Is it Bruschetta or Bruchetta ??? (https://www.foodbanter.com/general-cooking/454004-re-bruschetta-bruchetta.html)

bruce bowser 12-04-2021 02:21 PM

Is it Bruschetta or Bruchetta ???
 
On Thursday, October 19, 2000 at 3:00:00 AM UTC-4, PENMART01 wrote:
> In article >, "Kate" >
> writes:
> >"uur" > wrote in message
> hlink.net...
> >> > Any Italian who speaks proper, modern "Italian" knows how to pronounce

> >it
> >> > correctly. It is bruschetta with a hard k softened by an s.
> >> > Mayhap your friends are referring to it in their own dialect, albeit not
> >> > official Italian?
> >>
> >>
> >> Notwithstanding Kate's slightly pedantic response, the fact is that you
> >> might well hear the soft "sh" sound in bruschetta -- even in Italy --
> >> particularly if you are in Florence, where eleven (undici) is pronounced
> >> "undishi" and where other vestiges of Fiorentino dialect and pronunciation
> >> creep into the language.

> >
> >"slightly pedantic"... Them's fighting words ;-)! I didn't mean to be
> >pedantic (would anyone?) actually I just get a bit tired of hearing people
> >say that an "Italian" word is correctly pronounced one way when it is
> >obvious that their understanding of the history of Italy and how that
> >effects the languages of Italy - not proper Italian- is deficient. I
> >learned "proper", modern Italian.

> You learned "Standard Italian", there is no such thing as [a] "proper" Italian
> Language... unless you're a 'snoot': one who has an offensive air of
> superiority.
> Languages are dialectical, that is they deviate from 'Standard'. "Proper",
> there is no "proper". There is no "proper" Italian, "proper" French, "proper"
> Spanish, "proper" English, etal. All dialects within a language group are
> correct, none being more correct. No one converses using the Standard Literal
> form of a language outside the classroom, especially as to 'pronunciation', nor
> is it possible even within, as no two people are capable of exactly the same
> speech... as to pronunciation, the best one can do is approach the "Standard".
> ENCYCLOPÆDIA BRITANNICA
>
> Italian language
> Italian ITALIANO, Romance language spoken by some 66,000,000 persons in Italy
> (including Sicily and Sardinia), France (including Corsica), Switzerland, and
> other countries. It is spoken by large numbers of emigrants and their
> descendants in the Americas, especially in the United States, Argentina, and
> Canada. Written materials in Italian date from the 10th century (a set of court
> records with the testimony of the witnesses in the Italian vernacular), and the
> first literary work of length is the Ritmo Laurenziano ("Laurentian Rhythm") of
> the late 12th century.
> Although Italian has a standard literary form, <U>based on the _dialect_</U> of
> Florence, the common speech is dialectal or a local variant of standard
> Italian. The following dialect groups are distinguished: Northern Italian, or
> Gallo-Italian; Venetan, spoken in northeastern Italy; Tuscan (including


I've noticed that pico de gallo is similar to bruschetta.

Taxed and Spent 12-04-2021 04:33 PM

Is it Bruschetta or Bruchetta ???
 
On 4/12/2021 6:21 AM, bruce bowser wrote:
> On Thursday, October 19, 2000 at 3:00:00 AM UTC-4, PENMART01 wrote:
>> In article >, "Kate" >
>> writes:
>>> "uur" > wrote in message
>>> link.net...
>>>>> Any Italian who speaks proper, modern "Italian" knows how to pronounce
>>> it
>>>>> correctly. It is bruschetta with a hard k softened by an s.
>>>>> Mayhap your friends are referring to it in their own dialect, albeit not
>>>>> official Italian?
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Notwithstanding Kate's slightly pedantic response, the fact is that you
>>>> might well hear the soft "sh" sound in bruschetta -- even in Italy --
>>>> particularly if you are in Florence, where eleven (undici) is pronounced
>>>> "undishi" and where other vestiges of Fiorentino dialect and pronunciation
>>>> creep into the language.
>>>
>>> "slightly pedantic"... Them's fighting words ;-)! I didn't mean to be
>>> pedantic (would anyone?) actually I just get a bit tired of hearing people
>>> say that an "Italian" word is correctly pronounced one way when it is
>>> obvious that their understanding of the history of Italy and how that
>>> effects the languages of Italy - not proper Italian- is deficient. I
>>> learned "proper", modern Italian.

>> You learned "Standard Italian", there is no such thing as [a] "proper"

Italian
>> Language... unless you're a 'snoot': one who has an offensive air of
>> superiority.
>> Languages are dialectical, that is they deviate from 'Standard'. "Proper",
>> there is no "proper". There is no "proper" Italian, "proper" French, "proper"
>> Spanish, "proper" English, etal. All dialects within a language group are
>> correct, none being more correct. No one converses using the Standard Literal
>> form of a language outside the classroom, especially as to 'pronunciation', nor
>> is it possible even within, as no two people are capable of exactly the same
>> speech... as to pronunciation, the best one can do is approach the "Standard".
>> ENCYCLOPÆDIA BRITANNICA
>>
>> Italian language
>> Italian ITALIANO, Romance language spoken by some 66,000,000 persons in Italy
>> (including Sicily and Sardinia), France (including Corsica), Switzerland, and
>> other countries. It is spoken by large numbers of emigrants and their
>> descendants in the Americas, especially in the United States, Argentina, and
>> Canada. Written materials in Italian date from the 10th century (a set

of court
>> records with the testimony of the witnesses in the Italian vernacular), and the
>> first literary work of length is the Ritmo Laurenziano ("Laurentian Rhythm") of
>> the late 12th century.
>> Although Italian has a standard literary form, <U>based on the _dialect_</U> of
>> Florence, the common speech is dialectal or a local variant of standard
>> Italian. The following dialect groups are distinguished: Northern Italian, or
>> Gallo-Italian; Venetan, spoken in northeastern Italy; Tuscan (including

>
> I've noticed that pico de gallo is similar to bruschetta.
>



If you consider bread and no bread similar.


bruce bowser 12-04-2021 06:14 PM

Is it Bruschetta or Bruchetta ???
 
On Monday, April 12, 2021 at 11:33:07 AM UTC-4, Taxed and Spent wrote:
> On 4/12/2021 6:21 AM, bruce bowser wrote:
> > On Thursday, October 19, 2000 at 3:00:00 AM UTC-4, PENMART01 wrote:
> >> In article >, "Kate" >
> >> writes:
> >>> "uur" > wrote in message
> >>> link.net...
> >>>>> Any Italian who speaks proper, modern "Italian" knows how to pronounce
> >>> it
> >>>>> correctly. It is bruschetta with a hard k softened by an s.
> >>>>> Mayhap your friends are referring to it in their own dialect, albeit not
> >>>>> official Italian?
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>> Notwithstanding Kate's slightly pedantic response, the fact is that you
> >>>> might well hear the soft "sh" sound in bruschetta -- even in Italy --
> >>>> particularly if you are in Florence, where eleven (undici) is pronounced
> >>>> "undishi" and where other vestiges of Fiorentino dialect and pronunciation
> >>>> creep into the language.
> >>>
> >>> "slightly pedantic"... Them's fighting words ;-)! I didn't mean to be
> >>> pedantic (would anyone?) actually I just get a bit tired of hearing people
> >>> say that an "Italian" word is correctly pronounced one way when it is
> >>> obvious that their understanding of the history of Italy and how that
> >>> effects the languages of Italy - not proper Italian- is deficient. I
> >>> learned "proper", modern Italian.
> >> You learned "Standard Italian", there is no such thing as [a] "proper"

> Italian
> >> Language... unless you're a 'snoot': one who has an offensive air of
> >> superiority.
> >> Languages are dialectical, that is they deviate from 'Standard'. "Proper",
> >> there is no "proper". There is no "proper" Italian, "proper" French, "proper"
> >> Spanish, "proper" English, etal. All dialects within a language group are
> >> correct, none being more correct. No one converses using the Standard Literal
> >> form of a language outside the classroom, especially as to 'pronunciation', nor
> >> is it possible even within, as no two people are capable of exactly the same
> >> speech... as to pronunciation, the best one can do is approach the "Standard".
> >> ENCYCLOPÆDIA BRITANNICA
> >>
> >> Italian language
> >> Italian ITALIANO, Romance language spoken by some 66,000,000 persons in Italy
> >> (including Sicily and Sardinia), France (including Corsica), Switzerland, and
> >> other countries. It is spoken by large numbers of emigrants and their
> >> descendants in the Americas, especially in the United States, Argentina, and
> >> Canada. Written materials in Italian date from the 10th century (a set

> of court
> >> records with the testimony of the witnesses in the Italian vernacular), and the
> >> first literary work of length is the Ritmo Laurenziano ("Laurentian Rhythm") of
> >> the late 12th century.
> >> Although Italian has a standard literary form, <U>based on the _dialect_</U> of
> >> Florence, the common speech is dialectal or a local variant of standard
> >> Italian. The following dialect groups are distinguished: Northern Italian, or
> >> Gallo-Italian; Venetan, spoken in northeastern Italy; Tuscan (including

> >
> > I've noticed that pico de gallo is similar to bruschetta.
> >

> If you consider bread and no bread similar.


With 1,342 traditional recipes of Bruschetta? and 211 traditional recipes of Pico De Gallo?


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:10 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FoodBanter