Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
General Cooking (rec.food.cooking) For general food and cooking discussion. Foods of all kinds, food procurement, cooking methods and techniques, eating, etc. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
I have long since given up trying to find real German black bread here
in rural Florida, even though I really love the stuff, but a recent visit to the Dominican Republic whetted my appetite for the wonderful stuff once again when I was in a town with an excellent German baker. I have made it myself using various recipes from Internet sources and Joy of Cooking, and have been successful in making breads that are so morish that I find myself overeating, BUT these breads, though they are perfect in texture and appearance, don't have the characteristic aroma of German black bread, s I suspect that there is a missing ingredient that produces the characteristic and unmistakeable aroma or German black bread, the one that combines equally well with jams and preserves and with cheese and cold cuts. Anyone know what it is? Maybe I need to add more vinegar or molasses, or something else? Current ingredients: White bread flour 30% Whole wheat bread flour 20% Rye bread flour 50% Yeast Brown sugar Molasses Cocoa powder Salt Vinegar. |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
|
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
|
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
|
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
Reg wrote: > wrote: > > > Thanks to both responders. The cocoa powder gives the dark color. You > > can also use instant coffee powder. > > > > Will try the caraway too--maybe that is the aromatic ingredient. > > That would be my first guess, along with a few other spices > like fennel. I've seen it used in various recipes. Or the > specific type of vinegar used (cider, etc). Another lesser > possibility is the coloring agent. > > Black breads are often colored not just by the darker ingredients > like cocoa and/or coffee, but a coloring agent. The commercial > ones are pretty close to tasteless, but the "homemade" version > does impart some distinct caramel-ish type flavors. It's made by > cooking the heck out of sugar, through the dark brown stage, > all the way to black. The homemade version is rarely used > anymore because it can be downright dangerous to make, but I > thought I'd throw it out there nonetheless. > > Good luck in your quest. I love black bread, too. > > -- Thanks, Reg. I have a batch rising right now, in which I have used a liberal amount of Goya Apple Cider vinegar, and Brer Rabbit molasses, also Badia caraway seeds. I don't think fennel has anything to do with it, because I am well familiar with that flavor, which is similar to ouzo, and it is not that. It seems to me that the sugar-cooking stuff is pretty much covered by the term molasses, and that perhaps I need to use blackstrap molasses instead of the molasses which I am using, whose label gives little information, but which I suspect may be sugar beet molasses. See excerpts below from Wikipedia: Molasses or treacle is a thick syrup by-product from the processing of the sugarcane or sugar beet into sugar. (In some parts of the U.S., "molasses" also refers to sorghum syrup.) The word molasses comes from the Portuguese word melaço, which is in turn the Greek mellas - honey. The quality of molasses depends on the maturity of the sugar cane or beet, the amount of sugar extracted, and the method of extraction. Contents Cane molasses Sulphured molasses is made from green, not yellow, sugar cane and is treated with sulfur dioxide fumes during the sugar extraction process. The sugar cane plant is harvested and stripped of its leaves. Its juice is then extracted from the canes, usually by crushing or mashing. The juice is boiled to concentrate and promote the crystallisation of the sugar. The results of this first boiling and removal of sugar crystal is first molasses, which has the highest sugar content because comparatively little sugar has been extracted from the juice. Second molasses is created from a second boiling and sugar extraction, and has a slight bitter tinge to its taste. The third boiling of the sugar syrup gives blackstrap molasses. The majority of sucrose from the original juice has been crystallized but blackstrap molasses is still mostly sugar by calories[1], but unlike refined sugars, it contains significant amounts of vitamins and minerals. Blackstrap molasses is a source of calcium, magnesium, and iron. One tablespoon provides up to 20 percent of the daily value of each of those nutrients.[2][3].Blackstrap is often sold as a health supplement, as well as being used in the manufacture of cattle feed, and for other industrial uses. Sugar beet molasses Molasses that comes from the sugar beet is different from cane molasses. Only the syrup left from the final crystallisation stage is called molasses; intermediate syrups are referred to as high green and low green and these are recycled within the crystallisation plant to maximise extraction. Beet molasses is about 50% sugar by dry weight, predominantly sucrose but also containing significant amounts of glucose and fructose. The non-sugar content includes many salts such as calcium, potassium, oxalate and chloride. These are either as a result of concentration from the original plant material or as a result of chemicals used in the processing. As such, it is unpalatable and is mainly used as an additive to animal feed or as a fermentation feedstock. It is possible to extract additional sugar from beet molasses through a process known as molasses desugarisation. This technique exploits industrial scale chromatography to separate sucrose from non-sugar components. The technique is economically viable in trade protected areas where the price of sugar is supported above the world market price. As such it is practised in the US[4] and parts of Europe. |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
> wrote in message ups.com... >I have long since given up trying to find real German black bread here > in rural Florida, even though I really love the stuff, but a recent > visit to the Dominican Republic whetted my appetite for the wonderful > stuff once again when I was in a town with an excellent German baker. > > I have made it myself using various recipes from Internet sources and > Joy of Cooking, and have been successful in making breads that are so > morish that I find myself overeating, BUT these breads, though they are > perfect in texture and appearance, don't have the characteristic aroma > of German black bread, s I suspect that there is a missing ingredient > that produces the characteristic and unmistakeable aroma or German > black bread, the one that combines equally well with jams and preserves > and with cheese and cold cuts. > > Anyone know what it is? Maybe I need to add more vinegar or molasses, > or something else? > > Current ingredients: > > White bread flour 30% > Whole wheat bread flour 20% > Rye bread flour 50% > Yeast > Brown sugar > Molasses > Cocoa powder > Salt > Vinegar. > I've seen some commercial recipes reference a ground raisin product. I've always meant to try it but haven't done so yet. Pureed raisins are a common ingredient in a lot of foods. Janet |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
|
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
"Janet B." > wrote in message
... > > > wrote in message > ups.com... >>I have long since given up trying to find real German black bread here >> in rural Florida, even though I really love the stuff, but a recent >> visit to the Dominican Republic whetted my appetite for the wonderful >> stuff once again when I was in a town with an excellent German baker. >> >> I have made it myself using various recipes from Internet sources and >> Joy of Cooking, and have been successful in making breads that are so >> morish that I find myself overeating, BUT these breads, though they are >> perfect in texture and appearance, don't have the characteristic aroma >> of German black bread, s I suspect that there is a missing ingredient >> that produces the characteristic and unmistakeable aroma or German >> black bread, the one that combines equally well with jams and preserves >> and with cheese and cold cuts. >> >> Anyone know what it is? Maybe I need to add more vinegar or molasses, >> or something else? >> >> Current ingredients: >> >> White bread flour 30% >> Whole wheat bread flour 20% >> Rye bread flour 50% >> Yeast >> Brown sugar >> Molasses >> Cocoa powder >> Salt >> Vinegar. >> > I've seen some commercial recipes reference a ground raisin product. I've > always meant to try it but haven't done so yet. Pureed raisins are a > common ingredient in a lot of foods. > Janet Wouldn't that produce more of a fruity scent? I know the scent that the OP's talking about and I can't pin it down, either. |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
|
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
|
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
kuvasz guy wrote: > Sheldon wrote: > > wrote: > > > I have long since given up trying to find real German black bread here > > > in rural Florida, even though I really love the stuff, but a recent > > > visit to the Dominican Republic whetted my appetite for the wonderful > > > stuff once again when I was in a town with an excellent German baker. > > > > > > I have made it myself using various recipes from Internet sources and > > > Joy of Cooking, and have been successful in making breads that are so > > > morish that I find myself overeating, BUT these breads, though they are > > > perfect in texture and appearance, don't have the characteristic aroma > > > of German black bread, s I suspect that there is a missing ingredient > > > that produces the characteristic and unmistakeable aroma or German > > > black bread, the one that combines equally well with jams and preserves > > > and with cheese and cold cuts. > > > > > > Anyone know what it is? Maybe I need to add more vinegar or molasses, > > > or something else? > > > > > > Current ingredients: > > > > > > White bread flour 30% > > > Whole wheat bread flour 20% > > > Rye bread flour 50% > > > Yeast > > > Brown sugar > > > Molasses > > > Cocoa powder > > > Salt > > > Vinegar. > > > > The correct texture is from the particular flour used by professional > > bakers; "First Clear" or "Clear" flour, this is the least refined > > flour. And the aroma you're missing is from an ingredient called > > "Altus", professional bakers make this sour mash themselves from saved > > stale bread crusts. > > > > The color in black bread is from adding burnt sugar, an intensely > > strong liquid caramel, colorant used by professional bakers and in > > certain ethnic food dishes. Burnt sugar is inexpensive, an 8 oz bottle > > is like $3 and since you will use only a tsp or two at a time it will > > last like forever. > > > > I strongly recommend you get a copy of George Greenstein's "Secrets of > > a Jewish Baker". > > > > Sheldon > > Sheldon, > Can this bread be purchased locally? BTW, ever been to Cohen's in > Ellenville? Love the pumpernickel... They are supposedly famous for their raisin pumpernickle but I don't think they make a black bread. I haven't tried their products. http://cohensbakery.com/s/product_in...products_id=35 I used to buy real Russian black bread in Patchogue, NY and Brighton Beach, Brooklyn (Little Odessa). Sheldon |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
> wrote:
> I have made it myself using various recipes from Internet sources and > Joy of Cooking, and have been successful in making breads that are so > morish that I find myself overeating, BUT these breads, though they are > perfect in texture and appearance, don't have the characteristic aroma > of German black bread, s I suspect that there is a missing ingredient > that produces the characteristic and unmistakeable aroma or German > black bread, the one that combines equally well with jams and preserves > and with cheese and cold cuts. What kind of German black bread? There are many kinds here in Germany and they all taste different from each other. I would say that the most important factor is the kind(s) of flour used and, if there is more than one, in which proportion. Also, the percentage of bran in the flour makes a lot of difference. Victor |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
>>>> >>>> Anyone know what it is? Maybe I need to add more vinegar or molasses, >>>> or something else? I recently went on a great tour of a German Bakery in California. They said they couldn't get the right flavor or texture from rye grown in the U.S., so they import their flour from Germany. I've also had little success with dark rye. I've given up, but maybe I should start experimenting again. Jeneen |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
Sheldon wrote: > kuvasz guy wrote: > > Sheldon wrote: > > > wrote: > > > > I have long since given up trying to find real German black bread here > > > > in rural Florida, even though I really love the stuff, but a recent > > > > visit to the Dominican Republic whetted my appetite for the wonderful > > > > stuff once again when I was in a town with an excellent German baker. > > > > > > > > I have made it myself using various recipes from Internet sources and > > > > Joy of Cooking, and have been successful in making breads that are so > > > > morish that I find myself overeating, BUT these breads, though they are > > > > perfect in texture and appearance, don't have the characteristic aroma > > > > of German black bread, s I suspect that there is a missing ingredient > > > > that produces the characteristic and unmistakeable aroma or German > > > > black bread, the one that combines equally well with jams and preserves > > > > and with cheese and cold cuts. > > > > > > > > Anyone know what it is? Maybe I need to add more vinegar or molasses, > > > > or something else? > > > > > > > > Current ingredients: > > > > > > > > White bread flour 30% > > > > Whole wheat bread flour 20% > > > > Rye bread flour 50% > > > > Yeast > > > > Brown sugar > > > > Molasses > > > > Cocoa powder > > > > Salt > > > > Vinegar. > > > > > > The correct texture is from the particular flour used by professional > > > bakers; "First Clear" or "Clear" flour, this is the least refined > > > flour. And the aroma you're missing is from an ingredient called > > > "Altus", professional bakers make this sour mash themselves from saved > > > stale bread crusts. > > > > > > The color in black bread is from adding burnt sugar, an intensely > > > strong liquid caramel, colorant used by professional bakers and in > > > certain ethnic food dishes. Burnt sugar is inexpensive, an 8 oz bottle > > > is like $3 and since you will use only a tsp or two at a time it will > > > last like forever. > > > > > > I strongly recommend you get a copy of George Greenstein's "Secrets of > > > a Jewish Baker". > > > > > > Sheldon > > > > Sheldon, > > Can this bread be purchased locally? BTW, ever been to Cohen's in > > Ellenville? Love the pumpernickel... > > They are supposedly famous for their raisin pumpernickle but I don't > think they make a black bread. I haven't tried their products. > > http://cohensbakery.com/s/product_in...products_id=35 > > I used to buy real Russian black bread in Patchogue, NY and Brighton > Beach, Brooklyn (Little Odessa). > > Sheldon yep -- I buy the 3 pound loafs of raisin pumpernickel, let them throw it in the slicer... I don't eat rye as often, but that's also good... ...fred |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
Victor Sack wrote:
> > wrote: > > > I have made it myself using various recipes from Internet sources and > > Joy of Cooking, and have been successful in making breads that are so > > morish that I find myself overeating, BUT these breads, though they are > > perfect in texture and appearance, don't have the characteristic aroma > > of German black bread, s I suspect that there is a missing ingredient > > that produces the characteristic and unmistakeable aroma or German > > black bread, the one that combines equally well with jams and preserves > > and with cheese and cold cuts. > > What kind of German black bread? There are many kinds here in Germany > and they all taste different from each other. I would say that the most > important factor is the kind(s) of flour used and, if there is more than > one, in which proportion. Also, the percentage of bran in the flour > makes a lot of difference. > > Victor Thanks again to so many people who have offered suggestions. The fragrance is slightly sour, so I think the sour mash suggestion is the most likely. As far as the more obscure ideas about flours and so on, I am a bit sceptical, because I had excellent black bread the other day in the Dominican Republic, and will be back there again next week. In the DR it is hard to obtain any kind of quality ingredients other than plantains and coffee. As regards the question "what kind of German black bread?". I am sure there are many kinds of black bread, but there is a standard type that you can find (though it is many years since I visited Germany) in any supermarket, which is a dense and moist black bread that usually comes already sliced and wrapped in cellophane (if that is any help). The slices are completely rectangular and wider than they are high. Something like this: http://www.ireks.com/upload/1_Hambur...zbrot_6042.jpg or this one: http://www.marions-kochbuch.de/rezept/0987.htm which requires the use of buttermilk, "Rübenkraut" (I think this is molasses--sorry my German is kind of rusty). and sunflower seeds, as well as the usual 3 types of flour, yeast, and salt, and is cooked for 3 hours at 170° . After 2 hours it should be covered with "Backpapier" (I guess this is aluminum foil) so that it does not get too dark (damit das Brot nicht zu dunkel wird!). You can tell if it is done by klopfing a Fingerknöchel on the bottom of the bread to see if it sounds hollow (a bit like tapping it with your finger, I would say). Makes me wonder if buttermilk might be the "missing" ingredient. I think I will give this second recipe a try, but minus the sunflower seeds. |
Posted to rec.food.cooking
|
|||
|
|||
Black bread aroma/flavor question
> wrote:
> Thanks again to so many people who have offered suggestions. The > fragrance is slightly sour, so I think the sour mash suggestion is the > most likely. A lot of such breads are made with sourdough. > As far as the more obscure ideas about flours and so on, I > am a bit sceptical, because I had excellent black bread the other day > in the Dominican Republic, and will be back there again next week. In > the DR it is hard to obtain any kind of quality ingredients other than > plantains and coffee. There is little that is obscure about the flour - it is basically about whether it is rye, wheat, or a mixture, and about the amount of bran left in it. > As regards the question "what kind of German black bread?". I am sure > there are many kinds of black bread, but there is a standard type that > you can find (though it is many years since I visited Germany) in any > supermarket, which is a dense and moist black bread that usually comes > already sliced and wrapped in cellophane (if that is any help). The > slices are completely rectangular and wider than they are high. The problem is, there is no such standard type, the only exception I can think of being pumpernickel. However, judging by the picture and the recipe you posted, it is definitely not pumpernickel. > Something like this: > > http://www.ireks.com/upload/1_Hambur...zbrot_6042.jpg This looks a lot like some whole-grain rye breads sold in plastic wrappers here (BTW, good bread is always sold fresh and never in plastic wrappers here). It is pure, whole-grain rye made with sourdough, yeast, salt, perhaps spices, and with no other additions save for Rübenkraut or a caramel-syrup in case of industrial-type bread. If there is something like sunflower seeds added, it is always stated prominently on the label. > or this one: > > http://www.marions-kochbuch.de/rezept/0987.htm > > which requires the use of buttermilk, "Rübenkraut" (I think this is > molasses--sorry my German is kind of rusty). Rübenkraut is concentrated sugar-beet juice, a syrup, i.e. a kind of treacle. > and sunflower seeds, as > well as the usual 3 types of flour, yeast, and salt, and is cooked for > 3 hours at 170° . Neither sunflower seeds, nor 3 types of flour are typical for this kind of bread, if I understand your quest correctly. > After 2 hours it should be covered with "Backpapier" > (I guess this is aluminum foil) so that it does not get too dark (damit > das Brot nicht zu dunkel wird!). It is parchment paper. Victor |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Pyrazine aroma and flavor in Cabernet S. | Wine | |||
Bread-like aroma | Wine | |||
describing tea taste/flavor/aroma & maps | Tea | |||
Flavor Aroma of Concord Wines from Fresh Juice | Winemaking | |||
A strong, stimulating beverage with a distinctive aroma and complex flavor | Coffee |