FoodBanter.com

FoodBanter.com (https://www.foodbanter.com/)
-   Cooking Equipment (https://www.foodbanter.com/cooking-equipment/)
-   -   Comparative review of Japanese gyutos (https://www.foodbanter.com/cooking-equipment/31330-comparative-review-japanese-gyutos.html)

Fred 14-08-2004 10:34 AM

Comparative review of Japanese gyutos
 
This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so feel
free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:
http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005

Fred
Foodie Forums
http//www.foodieforums.com




Arturo 15-08-2004 10:50 AM

>This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so feel
>free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:
>http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
>
>Fred
>Foodie Forums
>http//www.foodieforums.com
>
>


Thank you very much for the reviews. I am looking forward to the Mac review
(especially if you choose to review the ultimate series). I currently have the
Misono 10.5" Moly series knife. It is wonderful. Any comments on the diffences
between these two series. I feel the need to add a 9" knife to my collection
and will probably choose between the Misono or Mac.

Arturo 15-08-2004 10:50 AM

>This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so feel
>free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:
>http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
>
>Fred
>Foodie Forums
>http//www.foodieforums.com
>
>


Thank you very much for the reviews. I am looking forward to the Mac review
(especially if you choose to review the ultimate series). I currently have the
Misono 10.5" Moly series knife. It is wonderful. Any comments on the diffences
between these two series. I feel the need to add a 9" knife to my collection
and will probably choose between the Misono or Mac.

Arturo 16-08-2004 07:34 AM

>>This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so feel
>>free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:
>>http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
>>
>>Fred
>>Foodie Forums
>>http//www.foodieforums.com
>>
>>

>
>Thank you very much for the reviews. I am looking forward to the Mac review
>(especially if you choose to review the ultimate series). I currently have
>the
>Misono 10.5" Moly series knife. It is wonderful. Any comments on the
>diffences
>between these two series. I feel the need to add a 9" knife to my collection
>and will probably choose between the Misono or Mac.
>


Btw... The Misono Ux10, Does it have its own type of Kullens? I thought I heard
something about perpendicular lines runing up and down the blade.

That Gelastin sure is a beutiful knife

I hear a Masamoto rep might be visiting Mutual Trading in the fall as well.
That might be worth waithing for. I have heard only good things about their
knives as well.

Arturo

Arturo 16-08-2004 07:34 AM

>>This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so feel
>>free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:
>>http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
>>
>>Fred
>>Foodie Forums
>>http//www.foodieforums.com
>>
>>

>
>Thank you very much for the reviews. I am looking forward to the Mac review
>(especially if you choose to review the ultimate series). I currently have
>the
>Misono 10.5" Moly series knife. It is wonderful. Any comments on the
>diffences
>between these two series. I feel the need to add a 9" knife to my collection
>and will probably choose between the Misono or Mac.
>


Btw... The Misono Ux10, Does it have its own type of Kullens? I thought I heard
something about perpendicular lines runing up and down the blade.

That Gelastin sure is a beutiful knife

I hear a Masamoto rep might be visiting Mutual Trading in the fall as well.
That might be worth waithing for. I have heard only good things about their
knives as well.

Arturo

Fred 17-08-2004 02:55 AM


"Arturo" > wrote in message
...
> >>This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so

feel
> >>free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:

>
>>http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
> >>
> >>Fred
> >>Foodie Forums
> >>http//www.foodieforums.com
> >>
> >>

> >
> >Thank you very much for the reviews. I am looking forward to the Mac

review
> >(especially if you choose to review the ultimate series). I currently

have
> >the
> >Misono 10.5" Moly series knife. It is wonderful. Any comments on the
> >diffences
> >between these two series. I feel the need to add a 9" knife to my

collection
> >and will probably choose between the Misono or Mac.
> >

>
> Btw... The Misono Ux10, Does it have its own type of Kullens? I thought I

heard
> something about perpendicular lines runing up and down the blade.
>
> That Gelastin sure is a beutiful knife
>
> I hear a Masamoto rep might be visiting Mutual Trading in the fall as

well.
> That might be worth waithing for. I have heard only good things about

their
> knives as well.
>
> Arturo


No the Misono UX10 has no kullens. I'm currently working with the new
Masamoto VG-10 gyuto in 240mm. It is really a very, very good knife. So
far I'm giving it all 5's. It will either tie or beat out the Misono
depending on blade hardness which takes a while to determine since I don't
have equipment for measuring it. I have to work until the blade dulls and
then sharpen it and that takes a while with the Japanese gyutos which hold
an edge very well.

The Glestain is an interesting looking knife. The blade is bit softer than
the blades on other similarly priced knives - Misono, Masamoto, and even
some cheaper knives - Kiyotsuna Josaku. Also it is slightly handle heavy
and I really don't like handle heaviness in a chef knife. It isn't severe
enough to cause me distress but it is noticeable and a little distracting to
me. Fit and finish are awesome, though.

I'm awaiting some Macs. I don't know which series. I have no experience
with them yet. Sorry.




Fred 17-08-2004 02:55 AM


"Arturo" > wrote in message
...
> >>This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so

feel
> >>free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:

>
>>http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
> >>
> >>Fred
> >>Foodie Forums
> >>http//www.foodieforums.com
> >>
> >>

> >
> >Thank you very much for the reviews. I am looking forward to the Mac

review
> >(especially if you choose to review the ultimate series). I currently

have
> >the
> >Misono 10.5" Moly series knife. It is wonderful. Any comments on the
> >diffences
> >between these two series. I feel the need to add a 9" knife to my

collection
> >and will probably choose between the Misono or Mac.
> >

>
> Btw... The Misono Ux10, Does it have its own type of Kullens? I thought I

heard
> something about perpendicular lines runing up and down the blade.
>
> That Gelastin sure is a beutiful knife
>
> I hear a Masamoto rep might be visiting Mutual Trading in the fall as

well.
> That might be worth waithing for. I have heard only good things about

their
> knives as well.
>
> Arturo


No the Misono UX10 has no kullens. I'm currently working with the new
Masamoto VG-10 gyuto in 240mm. It is really a very, very good knife. So
far I'm giving it all 5's. It will either tie or beat out the Misono
depending on blade hardness which takes a while to determine since I don't
have equipment for measuring it. I have to work until the blade dulls and
then sharpen it and that takes a while with the Japanese gyutos which hold
an edge very well.

The Glestain is an interesting looking knife. The blade is bit softer than
the blades on other similarly priced knives - Misono, Masamoto, and even
some cheaper knives - Kiyotsuna Josaku. Also it is slightly handle heavy
and I really don't like handle heaviness in a chef knife. It isn't severe
enough to cause me distress but it is noticeable and a little distracting to
me. Fit and finish are awesome, though.

I'm awaiting some Macs. I don't know which series. I have no experience
with them yet. Sorry.




Arturo 17-08-2004 07:42 AM

>
>"Arturo" > wrote in message
...
>> >>This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so

>feel
>> >>free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:

>>
>>>http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
>> >>
>> >>Fred
>> >>Foodie Forums
>> >>http//www.foodieforums.com
>> >>
>> >>
>> >
>> >Thank you very much for the reviews. I am looking forward to the Mac

>review
>> >(especially if you choose to review the ultimate series). I currently

>have
>> >the
>> >Misono 10.5" Moly series knife. It is wonderful. Any comments on the
>> >diffences
>> >between these two series. I feel the need to add a 9" knife to my

>collection
>> >and will probably choose between the Misono or Mac.
>> >

>>
>> Btw... The Misono Ux10, Does it have its own type of Kullens? I thought I

>heard
>> something about perpendicular lines runing up and down the blade.
>>
>> That Gelastin sure is a beutiful knife
>>
>> I hear a Masamoto rep might be visiting Mutual Trading in the fall as

>well.
>> That might be worth waithing for. I have heard only good things about

>their
>> knives as well.
>>
>> Arturo

>
>No the Misono UX10 has no kullens. I'm currently working with the new
>Masamoto VG-10 gyuto in 240mm. It is really a very, very good knife. So
>far I'm giving it all 5's. It will either tie or beat out the Misono
>depending on blade hardness which takes a while to determine since I don't
>have equipment for measuring it. I have to work until the blade dulls and
>then sharpen it and that takes a while with the Japanese gyutos which hold
>an edge very well.
>
>The Glestain is an interesting looking knife. The blade is bit softer than
>the blades on other similarly priced knives - Misono, Masamoto, and even
>some cheaper knives - Kiyotsuna Josaku. Also it is slightly handle heavy
>and I really don't like handle heaviness in a chef knife. It isn't severe
>enough to cause me distress but it is noticeable and a little distracting to
>me. Fit and finish are awesome, though.
>
>I'm awaiting some Macs. I don't know which series. I have no experience
>with them yet. Sorry.
>


Thank you for your hard work. I have bought most of my knives with out the
benifit of a lot of reviews and can't say I regret one purchase. But it sure
way harder.

I have a MAC stainless sushi knife and think the world of it, but have never
tried their chef knives.

About the Gelastin: I was also intrigued because it is a bit heavier than the
Misono. I think it would be nice to have a bit more heft on the blade. I always
worry about the blade holding up to chicken bones and such. Although I have had
my Misono almost a year and it has held up well except for a bit of color on
the handle fading.

How does the Masamoto weigh in?

Jeffrey Dunnam 18-08-2004 06:36 AM

Thanks for the link and your reviews Fred. This sort of info is of great
interest to me.
"Fred" > wrote in message
...
> This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so

feel
> free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:
> http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
>
> Fred
> Foodie Forums
> http//www.foodieforums.com
>
>
>




Jeffrey Dunnam 18-08-2004 06:36 AM

Thanks for the link and your reviews Fred. This sort of info is of great
interest to me.
"Fred" > wrote in message
...
> This might be of interest to fans of Japanese cutlery. I wrote it so

feel
> free to direct any questions at me. The link should work. It is:
> http://www.foodieforums.com//ubb/ult...c;f=5;t=000005
>
> Fred
> Foodie Forums
> http//www.foodieforums.com
>
>
>





All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:28 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FoodBanter