Could someone point me to a source for judging/rating chocolate(s). I have
the generalities down -- but am looking for a quotable source.

Thanks in Advance
SGC

at Thu, 01 Apr 2004 12:24:15 GMT in >,
(SGC) wrote :

>Could someone point me to a source for judging/rating chocolate(s). I have
>the generalities down -- but am looking for a quotable source.
>
>Thanks in Advance
>SGC
>
>

My favourite, in terms of giving a realistic overview, is in Sandra
Boynton's "Chocolate: The Consuming Passion" (ISBN 0-89480-199-6, Workman
Publishing, 1982) "Evaluating Chocolate" - pp. 69-71. The book, btw, is a
classic which any serious chocoholic should have. Lots of good facts
presented in an humourous, tongue-in-cheek way.

On-line, Domori's guide to tasting (found at http://www.domori.com) is
nicely comprehensive. It isn't exactly a neutral source: Domori is a
(superb) chocolate manufacturer, but it does have a pretty detailed
explanation.

Seventy Percent's system (http://www.seventypercent.com) is somewhat
idiosyncratic, and IMHO doesn't put enough weight on the basic flavour of
the chocolate, but it's semi-"objective" in the sense that it tries to come
up with a numerical figure based on clearly established criteria.

However, there is no standardised, uniform way to judge chocolate, at least
not yet. I don't think, however, that a system can be that far away, given
the emerging popularity of chocolate in a similar context to wine. I think
the key ingredient that's needed to make it happen is some way to bring
together major industry players and the serious, dedicated chocoholics
round the world who regularly taste many chocolates. I envision some sort
of association with regional sections, open to membership both by
individuals and by organisations, which could coordinate and manage
activities, chocolate tastings, etc. with people and companies spread over
many countries.
--
Alex Rast

(remove d., .7, not, and .NOSPAM to reply)

On 04-04-01 22:45:57, Alex Rast wrote:

> However, there is no standardised, uniform way to judge chocolate, at least
> not yet. I don't think, however, that a system can be that far away, given
> the emerging popularity of chocolate in a similar context to wine.

.... And given that even with wine, 2 different tasters will use mostly
disjunct adjectives to describe the taste and typically even disagree
about where the wine originates from. ;-) Taste still doesn't seem up to
be fitted in a standarized uniform system beyond the very basics.

> the key ingredient that's needed to make it happen is some way to bring
> together major industry players and the serious, dedicated chocoholics
> round the world who regularly taste many chocolates.

I'm all up for this heavy duty task! My compensation is even minimal!
;-)


--
http://lars.marowsky-bree.de/disclaimer.html
http://www.amazon.de/exec/obidos/wis.../ref=wl_em_to/