View Single Post
  #262 (permalink)   Report Post  
Posted to alt.animals.ethics.vegetarian,alt.food.vegan,talk.politics.animals
Leif Erikson[_2_] Leif Erikson[_2_] is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 86
Default The Status of animals

Karen Winter attempted to explain her error:
> Leif Erikson wrote:
>
> Karen Winter lied:
>
> >>The system was set up by an act of Congress, and Congress
> >>are the representatives of the people.

>
> > Congress may not authorize the federal government to do things that the
> > Constitution does not allow it to do. This is basic civics.

>
> If it is not stated specifically in the Constitution, then
> powers are reserved to the States *OR* to the people.
> As their elected representatives, Congress are the people.


This is simply false. Congress is the body of the people's elected
representatives *only* for the purpose of the federal government.
Congress enacts federal laws. They may *only* constitutionally enact
federal laws in areas allowed to them by the Constitution.

Your interpretations of the Constitution are getting screwier all the
time. First, the Constitution does not tell Congress the areas in
which they may *not* act; it tells them the areas in which they *are*
authorized to act, and everything else is BY PRESUMPTION forbidden to
them.

Secondly, Congress is NOT "the people". It is the body of the people's
representatives *only* for the purpose of the federal government.