Always put quotes around "vegan"
****wit David Harrison - convicted for breeding fighting dogs - lied:
>>>>>>>>> There's the fact that it's a very significant aspect of human
>>>>>>>>> influence on animals.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> You keep saying its significant but you can't say how
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> It allows billions of animals to get to experience life.
No significance.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> No it doesn't. Our desire to consume animal products leads to them
>>>>>> existing in the first place,
>>>>>
>>>>> That's what's significant,
Not significant.
>>>>
>>>> Right, so what?
>>>
>>> So we have no ethical reason to avoid eating meat
We have no ethical reason to want animals to "get to experience life".
>>>
>>> "abstaining from meat saves future animals from life" - "Dutch"
>>
>> That made no sense.
>
> It's your quote
It's not a quote.
>>>>> and refusing to consider that aspect of the
>>>>> situation
Nothing to consider.
>>>>
>>>> You're not seeing any "big picture", you're seeing a narrow, trumped up
>>>> picture.
>>>
>>> I'm pointing out significant things
No. You're blabbering about things with no significance at all.
>>
>> You're not seeing anything significant.
>
> The lives of the animlas humans kill deserve as much or more consideration
They deserve no consideration - zero. It is not important in any way
that livestock animals "get to experience life". This has been proved.
>>>>>> our desire to alleviate their suffering then doing
>>>>>> something about it "allows billions of animals to enjoy lives of
>>>>>> positive value". You're not adding anything of value by "considering
>>>>>> what they get out of it"
They get *nothing* "out of it."
>>>>> ONLY an eliminationist has reason to oppose considering what happens
>>>>> when AW is successful
"when AW is successful" - bullshit cracker-speak. That's just vomit.
>>>>
>>>> I don't oppose considering what happens when AW is successful, I oppose
>>>> "considering what they get out of it" because it doesn't accomplish
>>>> anything.
>>>
>>> It suggests that providing lives
It's meaningless.
>>
>> It does nothing.
>
> That's a blatant lie since
It's not a lie. Causing animals to "get to experience life", which is
all you care about, is ethically meaningless. Proved.
|