On Jan 6, 12:13�am, Seymour > wrote:
> On Dec 27 2009, 7:05�am, DaleW > wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> > On Dec 25, 4:54�pm, Seymour > wrote:
>
> > > It's a 2005 Chanson Gevrey-Chambertin and I can't find a review for it
> > > anywhere.
>
> > > Any tips or informed opinions? Quoting from the Chanson web page . . ..
>
> > > Site : Gevrey Chambertin is located in the "C�te de Nuits". The grapes
> > > stem from a selected plot in the northern part of Appellation "Gevrey
> > > Chambertin" located on a mid slope and bordering the Premiers Crus.
> > > The grapes are sourced from a partner winegrower. Picking of the
> > > grapes by our teams.
>
> > > I'm wondering how the C�te de Nuits stacks up against the other
> > > appellations of Bourgogne? �I once read that Napoleon would not go
> > > into battle without his many casks of red Montrachet right along with
> > > his caissons and cannon.
> > > --
> > > S.
>
> > Only one review on CT, don't know the reviewer so not sure how
> > reliable, but he liked it:http://www.cellartracker.com/wine.asp?iWine=440008
>
> > As Santiago says, Gevrey-Chambertin is the appellation. The Cote d'Or
> > is the most famous subregion of Burgundy, it's commonly divided into
> > northern half (Cote de Nuits) and southern (Cote de Beaune). Gevrey is
> > typically earthy and a bit gamey as he also said. I'd call it a more
> > masculine style in general than say Chambolle.
>
> > Chanson is a large negociant, not sure how their Gevrey typically
> > stacks up, but 2005 is a very good vintage.- Hide quoted text -
>
> > - Show quoted text -
>
> Totally got the terminology balled up there, didn't I. �Been so many
> years since I seriously studied the matter I no longer know my
> appellations from my terroirs or domaines. �I was somewhat
> disappointed with the wine, frankly and can well see why you'd both
> describe it as "gamey" compared to the delicacy that I once found so
> much to my delight in a particularly beautiful estate bottled Beaune
> that I enjoyed too many years ago to recall the particular maison.
> This, from Chanson I found much too rough to my tastes.
>
> There is a distinct flavor I always look for in a pinot noir which I
> was hard put to bring out to my taste in this. I guess that long gone
> bottle from Beaune has spoiled me! However, just of late I've been
> greatly surprised to discover that this grape is grown in the Pfaltz
> region of Germany--even so far north as that! Some I suppose would
> find it pale, weak and watery by comparison to what comes from the
> Cote d'Or, but that distinctive flavor that I must have or be
> disappointed is there, even when it's being bought in bulk, imported
> by E & J Gallo (of all people) and bottled behind their Turning Leaf
> label for something like $6.49. �I would have preferred a 5 buck
> Beaujolais over this pinot from Gevrey. �With a name like "Montrachet"
> on the label, I should have been sitting there like I had rubies
> rolling around on my tongue, n'est ce pas?
>
> Thanks to you both for the help!
> --
> Seymour- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

I'm not sure I get the connection between Montrachet and Gevrey
Chambertin. One is in the Cote de Beaune (Montrachet) and one is in
the Cote de Nuits (Gevrey) two different places. FYI, Chanson is a
huge negociant owned by an even larger conglomerate owned by
Bollinger.