![]() |
|
Welcome to FoodBanter.com forums which provide access to the finest food and drink related newsgroups. You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most newsgroup discussions and access our other FREE features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics to the food related newsgroups, communicate privately with other FoodBanter.com members (PM), respond to polls, upload your own photos and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today! If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact support. |
|
|||||||
| Tea (rec.drink.tea) Discussion relating to tea, the world's second most consumed beverage (after water), made by infusing or boiling the leaves of the tea plant (C. sinensis or close relatives) in water. |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes |
|
|||
|
This was the green Xiaguan(left) tuocha I could buy locally till early
2005. Now no green tuocha since. Luckily I stocked up for buck each. Before I got dangerous in Chinese I sent one to Sasha and he said the production date on the bottom of the box(center) was Jan 2000. My box shows the yi character for the month. This box shows the jiu character but the year is the ling character. Everybody scoffed and said probably a forgery because Xiaguan didn't print production information on their boxes. I came across this picture on a Japanese website with the certification(right) from 1999: http://i14.tinypic.com/34eqb86.jpg Jim |
|
|||
|
Space Cowboy wrote: This was the green Xiaguan(left) tuocha I could buy locally till early 2005. Now no green tuocha since. Luckily I stocked up for buck each. Before I got dangerous in Chinese I sent one to Sasha and he said the production date on the bottom of the box(center) was Jan 2000. My box shows the yi character for the month. This box shows the jiu character but the year is the ling character. Everybody scoffed and said probably a forgery because Xiaguan didn't print production information on their boxes. I came across this picture on a Japanese website with the certification(right) from 1999: http://i14.tinypic.com/34eqb86.jpg Jim So this is a picture of your tea? Or someone else's? Do you have a picture of the tea itself, and not just the box? |
|
|||
|
MarshalN wrote:
Space Cowboy wrote: This was the green Xiaguan(left) tuocha I could buy locally till early 2005. Now no green tuocha since. Luckily I stocked up for buck each. Before I got dangerous in Chinese I sent one to Sasha and he said the production date on the bottom of the box(center) was Jan 2000. My box shows the yi character for the month. This box shows the jiu character but the year is the ling character. Everybody scoffed and said probably a forgery because Xiaguan didn't print production information on their boxes. I came across this picture on a Japanese website with the certification(right) from 1999: http://i14.tinypic.com/34eqb86.jpg Jim So this is a picture of your tea? Or someone else's? Do you have a picture of the tea itself, and not just the box? It's a picture from the Internet. Everything is the same except for the yue. The tuocha has lots of white bud and remaining green area on top fading to dark purple on the side ( I remember one of the first ones I tried looked much more green than this). It has the embossed G character. The wrapper has two lengthy columns of different Chinese characters down each side. You will probably know but what does the field "36 ge yue" indicate? Jim |
|
|||
|
Space Cowboy wrote: It's a picture from the Internet. Everything is the same except for the yue. The tuocha has lots of white bud and remaining green area on top fading to dark purple on the side ( I remember one of the first ones I tried looked much more green than this). It has the embossed G character. The wrapper has two lengthy columns of different Chinese characters down each side. You will probably know but what does the field "36 ge yue" indicate? Jim I seem to remember reading about this on Sanzui that the ones with those dates are fake -- later date. And I don't think they started putting the embossed G on the tuo until the last year or two. |
|
|||
|
Jing remarked the embossed G started in 2003:
http://tinyurl.com/ye3nh6 This provenance with the tael(bulk) ticket and my tuos on hand suggest otherwise. http://i14.tinypic.com/34eqb86.jpg You really have to ask yourself the question who is Chinatown riped me off for a buck tuo assuming it was fake? I'm still curious about that '36 ge yue' meaning. If it means something like the 'next 36 months' I think it would be possible to pickup an embossed G tuo with the year on the bottom of the box and conclude incorrectly which year it started. At the minimum the tael ticket and the information on the box ties together. Jim MarshalN wrote: Space Cowboy wrote: It's a picture from the Internet. Everything is the same except for the yue. The tuocha has lots of white bud and remaining green area on top fading to dark purple on the side ( I remember one of the first ones I tried looked much more green than this). It has the embossed G character. The wrapper has two lengthy columns of different Chinese characters down each side. You will probably know but what does the field "36 ge yue" indicate? Jim I seem to remember reading about this on Sanzui that the ones with those dates are fake -- later date. And I don't think they started putting the embossed G on the tuo until the last year or two. |
|
|||
|
It's a link I uploaded this morning to Tinyurl for a post Jing made in
this group. I just doubled checked and it is bringing up the RFDT post. This is the ugly url: http://groups.google.com/group/rec.f...7?dmode=source Jim Michael Plant wrote: Space Cowboy Jing remarked the embossed G started in 2003: http://tinyurl.com/ye3nh6 Jim, this link is dead. Michael |
|
|||
|
Well duh. Jing said the Te tuo was embossed in 2003. This is the Jia
tuo and first embossed in 95 so it can't be an anachronism.. Jim Space Cowboy wrote: It's a link I uploaded this morning to Tinyurl for a post Jing made in this group. I just doubled checked and it is bringing up the RFDT post. This is the ugly url: http://groups.google.com/group/rec.f...7?dmode=source Jim Michael Plant wrote: Space Cowboy Jing remarked the embossed G started in 2003: http://tinyurl.com/ye3nh6 Jim, this link is dead. Michael |
|
|||
|
The timeline is actually more hazy than what Jing mentioned.
The 'Jia Ji" tuo with the old imprint stopped production in 1993, and the 'Jia Ji' tuo with the "G" imprint began in June 1996. So there was a good three years inbetween. There are 3 types of 100gm tuos with that "G" imprint, not two. The last one is the 'Jin Si' tuo with a limited production. Xiaguan did and does print dates of production on the bottom of their boxes, though not all of them. In the beginning they used blue print ink, then sometime after 2001 they uses laser print. '36 months' is the 'Best Used By / Best Before' date. This is more of a formality than an actual warranty. Under China's export regulations for perishable items, it is mandatory that a warranty date be inserted. Many producers got around this regulation by putting either '12 months' or '36 months' or a time frame so that the health and food regulations officials won't get on their backs. Danny "Space Cowboy" wrote in message ups.com... Well duh. Jing said the Te tuo was embossed in 2003. This is the Jia tuo and first embossed in 95 so it can't be an anachronism.. Jim Space Cowboy wrote: It's a link I uploaded this morning to Tinyurl for a post Jing made in this group. I just doubled checked and it is bringing up the RFDT post. This is the ugly url: http://groups.google.com/group/rec.f...7?dmode=source Jim Michael Plant wrote: Space Cowboy Jing remarked the embossed G started in 2003: http://tinyurl.com/ye3nh6 Jim, this link is dead. Michael |
|
|||
|
Thanks Danny for the additional clarification on the Xiaguan use of
dates on their tuos. Just as I thought I should throw my Millennia tuocha away because it exceeds the 36 ge yue according to the health department, supposedly. I will say I was shocked at the almost purple patina when I opened one up the past couple of days. It wasn't the way I remembered when I first bought some early this decade. I scraped the one for a taste test and it was the way I remembered. I have other sheng I like better but this is the oldest chronologically. Jim .. samarkand wrote: The timeline is actually more hazy than what Jing mentioned. The 'Jia Ji" tuo with the old imprint stopped production in 1993, and the 'Jia Ji' tuo with the "G" imprint began in June 1996. So there was a good three years inbetween. There are 3 types of 100gm tuos with that "G" imprint, not two. The last one is the 'Jin Si' tuo with a limited production. Xiaguan did and does print dates of production on the bottom of their boxes, though not all of them. In the beginning they used blue print ink, then sometime after 2001 they uses laser print. '36 months' is the 'Best Used By / Best Before' date. This is more of a formality than an actual warranty. Under China's export regulations for perishable items, it is mandatory that a warranty date be inserted. Many producers got around this regulation by putting either '12 months' or '36 months' or a time frame so that the health and food regulations officials won't get on their backs. Danny ....for the curious use Google... |
|
|||
|
Space Cowboy wrote: Thanks Danny for the additional clarification on the Xiaguan use of dates on their tuos. Just as I thought I should throw my Millennia tuocha away because it exceeds the 36 ge yue according to the health department, supposedly. I will say I was shocked at the almost purple patina when I opened one up the past couple of days. It wasn't the way I remembered when I first bought some early this decade. I scraped the one for a taste test and it was the way I remembered. I have other sheng I like better but this is the oldest chronologically. Rather than worry about the tea's supposed age.... how does it taste? How does it look? You're not reselling your tea, so whether it is actually 15 years old or not.... doesn't really matter, does it? So long as it tastes good ![]() |
|
|||
|
Most puer doesn't come with a date provenance. You have to take
somebody's word for it. The ticking of the clock adds more to the value than aging of the taste. You notice most discussion in this group starts with how old is the puer followed by how great it taste or the corollary it can't taste good because its not old. My puer economic advice to investors buy the cheapest recent crops and sell them in the future for more money to those who think time is more important than taste. Mine will probably go up the crematorium shute with me if it doesn't cost my estate extra but I leave that decision to the court appointed Executor. Jim PS This post wasn't directed at MarshalN who is entirely correct that it is more about taste than dates but I think learned something about Xiaguan tuo dating from the Danny and Jing posts who I thank again. I just wished I had some tuo with the jiushi niandai stamped on it. MarshalN wrote: Space Cowboy wrote: Thanks Danny for the additional clarification on the Xiaguan use of dates on their tuos. Just as I thought I should throw my Millennia tuocha away because it exceeds the 36 ge yue according to the health department, supposedly. I will say I was shocked at the almost purple patina when I opened one up the past couple of days. It wasn't the way I remembered when I first bought some early this decade. I scraped the one for a taste test and it was the way I remembered. I have other sheng I like better but this is the oldest chronologically. Rather than worry about the tea's supposed age.... how does it taste? How does it look? You're not reselling your tea, so whether it is actually 15 years old or not.... doesn't really matter, does it? So long as it tastes good ![]() |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Golden Sail Yunnan Tuocha? | Dominic T. | Tea | 23 | 08-10-2006 04:51 PM |
| Found a Tuocha in East Portland, OR | stePH | Tea | 50 | 23-10-2005 02:47 AM |
| Chinatown Yunnan Tuocha | The Laughing Rat | Tea | 9 | 26-02-2005 03:19 AM |
| A bottomless cup of cooked tuocha | Space Cowboy | Tea | 3 | 13-10-2004 02:46 PM |
| Meaning and scope of "bingcha" and "tuocha"? | Joel Reicher | Tea | 20 | 29-09-2004 01:16 PM |