On Apr 29, 1:41�pm, Mark Lipton wrote:
DaleW wrote:
great post.
Mark, ordered a bottle of the Argiles, you made it sound tempting!

Other Patients on Wine Therapy disagreed with my assessment of this wine
as crisp. �It seems that Chidaine's '05 Vouvrays have become rather
controversial on the Wine Internet, so be prepared to disagree with me,
too ;-) �FWIW, I think that our bottle was a trifle colder than most
people may drink their Vouvrays, so perhaps that accounts for some of
the difference in perception...

Mark Lipton

--
alt.food.wine FAQ: �http://winefaq.hostexcellence.com

Anyone I know? I tend to trust those I've found common ground with
more than random tasters.
Just looked up Gilman's comments on '05 Argiles. I won't post whole
thing here, but includes:
3 g/l RS, On the palate the wine is medium-full,,,,,,,with beautiful
focus and zest, and a very long, very minerally backend that displays
outstanding grip and cut. 92"
We'll see!